{ "schemaVersion": "static-blv-three-agent/3", "tool": "wave", "summary": { "correct": 20, "false-positive": 48, "duplicate": 193, "unsure": 0, "excluded": 204, "total": 465, "inScope": 104, "outsideTarget": 361, "duplicateInScope": 36, "duplicateOutsideTarget": 157 }, "protocol": { "baseVotesInheritedFrom": "multi-agent-v2", "additionalDuplicateReviewers": 3, "duplicateMajority": "2 of 3", "scopeIndependentOfDecision": true, "excludedCanonicalAllowed": true, "withinToolOnly": true, "humanConfirmed": false }, "reviews": [ { "errorId": "ST0049", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G035", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0049", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0049", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0049" }, { "errorId": "ST0050", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G036", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0050", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0050", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0050" }, { "errorId": "ST0051", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G037", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "DOM/source and AX expose a View-product cover link and a second full-name link for the same product in each card, with only badges between. Inferred consequence: sequential keyboard/link navigation repeats the same product action before purchase controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes separate cover and title links to each same product in one card. Inferred: sequential link/keyboard navigation repeats the same product destination; not merely an equal-URL inference." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes a View-product cover link followed by a same-product title link to the identical product in each card. These are repeated product-opening stops within one card, adding keyboard stops and repeated SR announcements; consequence inferred from AX, not measured keystrokes." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: DOM/source and AX expose a View-product cover link and a second full-name link for the same product in each card, with only badges between. Inferred consequence: sequential keyboard/link navigation repeats the same product action before purchase controls. | B: AX exposes separate cover and title links to each same product in one card. Inferred: sequential link/keyboard navigation repeats the same product destination; not merely an equal-URL inference. | C: AX exposes a View-product cover link followed by a same-product title link to the identical product in each card. These are repeated product-opening stops within one card, adding keyboard stops and repeated SR announcements; consequence inferred from AX, not measured keystrokes.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0051", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0051", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0051" }, { "errorId": "ST0052", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G037", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0051", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "DOM/source and AX expose a View-product cover link and a second full-name link for the same product in each card, with only badges between. Inferred consequence: sequential keyboard/link navigation repeats the same product action before purchase controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes separate cover and title links to each same product in one card. Inferred: sequential link/keyboard navigation repeats the same product destination; not merely an equal-URL inference." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes a View-product cover link followed by a same-product title link to the identical product in each card. These are repeated product-opening stops within one card, adding keyboard stops and repeated SR announcements; consequence inferred from AX, not measured keystrokes." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0051 (P03; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: DOM/source and AX expose a View-product cover link and a second full-name link for the same product in each card, with only badges between. Inferred consequence: sequential keyboard/link navigation repeats the same product action before purchase controls. | B: AX exposes separate cover and title links to each same product in one card. Inferred: sequential link/keyboard navigation repeats the same product destination; not merely an equal-URL inference. | C: AX exposes a View-product cover link followed by a same-product title link to the identical product in each card. These are repeated product-opening stops within one card, adding keyboard stops and repeated SR announcements; consequence inferred from AX, not measured keystrokes.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0052", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0052", "duplicateProposal": "P03", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The frozen Tv constructor emits the cover and title links to the same product for all three instances. One constructor change consolidating those named links removes this precise repeated-stop defect across the three products; inference from source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied Tv source is one shared product-card constructor generating the same cover/title two-link defect for all three products. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the listed findings." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The frozen Tv product-card constructor creates both product-image and product-name links for all three CVS instances. Consolidating that shared product-opening structure fixes the same repeated-stop defect in each instance; same category alone is not the basis." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0052" }, { "errorId": "ST0053", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G037", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0051", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "DOM/source and AX expose a View-product cover link and a second full-name link for the same product in each card, with only badges between. Inferred consequence: sequential keyboard/link navigation repeats the same product action before purchase controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes separate cover and title links to each same product in one card. Inferred: sequential link/keyboard navigation repeats the same product destination; not merely an equal-URL inference." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes a View-product cover link followed by a same-product title link to the identical product in each card. These are repeated product-opening stops within one card, adding keyboard stops and repeated SR announcements; consequence inferred from AX, not measured keystrokes." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0051 (P03; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: DOM/source and AX expose a View-product cover link and a second full-name link for the same product in each card, with only badges between. Inferred consequence: sequential keyboard/link navigation repeats the same product action before purchase controls. | B: AX exposes separate cover and title links to each same product in one card. Inferred: sequential link/keyboard navigation repeats the same product destination; not merely an equal-URL inference. | C: AX exposes a View-product cover link followed by a same-product title link to the identical product in each card. These are repeated product-opening stops within one card, adding keyboard stops and repeated SR announcements; consequence inferred from AX, not measured keystrokes.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0053", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0053", "duplicateProposal": "P03", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The frozen Tv constructor emits the cover and title links to the same product for all three instances. One constructor change consolidating those named links removes this precise repeated-stop defect across the three products; inference from source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied Tv source is one shared product-card constructor generating the same cover/title two-link defect for all three products. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the listed findings." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The frozen Tv product-card constructor creates both product-image and product-name links for all three CVS instances. Consolidating that shared product-opening structure fixes the same repeated-stop defect in each instance; same category alone is not the basis." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0053" }, { "errorId": "ST0054", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G038", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0054", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0054", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0054" }, { "errorId": "ST0055", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G039", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0055", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0055", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0055" }, { "errorId": "ST0056", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G038", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0054", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0054 (E032); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-oBKZbM_A.css\", \"selector\": \".pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill\"}]；目标共享 rgb(66, 66, 66)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0056", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0056", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E032", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The CVS badge variants share the combined .pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill font-size declaration and actual 10.72px. One change to that exact 0.67rem badge-size rule addresses the reported small-text mechanism across these matching badge treatments." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These product-status badges share the same local badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10.72px, with matching displayed treatment. One badge-size change covers the repeated text-size mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The listed product badges use the shared .pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill font-size declaration, confirmed by the same computed 10.72px size. Raising this one badge-size declaration covers their text-size mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-oBKZbM_A.css\", \"selector\": \".pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill\"}]；目标共享 rgb(66, 66, 66)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0056" }, { "errorId": "ST0057", "site": "cvs", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/00-cvs/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/00-cvs/dist", "reviewGroup": "G038", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0054", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0054 (E032); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-oBKZbM_A.css\", \"selector\": \".pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill\"}]；目标共享 rgb(66, 66, 66)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0057", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0057", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E032", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The CVS badge variants share the combined .pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill font-size declaration and actual 10.72px. One change to that exact 0.67rem badge-size rule addresses the reported small-text mechanism across these matching badge treatments." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These product-status badges share the same local badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10.72px, with matching displayed treatment. One badge-size change covers the repeated text-size mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The listed product badges use the shared .pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill font-size declaration, confirmed by the same computed 10.72px size. Raising this one badge-size declaration covers their text-size mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-oBKZbM_A.css\", \"selector\": \".pill-badge, .deal-badge, .match-pill\"}]；目标共享 rgb(66, 66, 66)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0057" }, { "errorId": "ST0068", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G044", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0068", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0068", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0068" }, { "errorId": "ST0069", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G044", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0068", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0068 (E003); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".trust-strip span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0069", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0069", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E003", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, these trust-statistic descriptions share .trust-strip span and the same computed color/size. One local description-color repair covers this group; no cross-tool merging or general contrast verdict is implied." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/CarGurus, the same trust-strip caption component and matching computed foreground tie these instances to one local caption-color repair. No cross-tool merging or general-validity finding is implied." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the trust-strip descriptions use the same .trust-strip span color source and actual foreground. They share one local color repair; the corresponding axe findings remain a separate tool group." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".trust-strip span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0069" }, { "errorId": "ST0070", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G044", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0068", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0068 (E003); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".trust-strip span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0070", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0070", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E003", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, these trust-statistic descriptions share .trust-strip span and the same computed color/size. One local description-color repair covers this group; no cross-tool merging or general contrast verdict is implied." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/CarGurus, the same trust-strip caption component and matching computed foreground tie these instances to one local caption-color repair. No cross-tool merging or general-validity finding is implied." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the trust-strip descriptions use the same .trust-strip span color source and actual foreground. They share one local color repair; the corresponding axe findings remain a separate tool group." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".trust-strip span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0070" }, { "errorId": "ST0071", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G044", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0068", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0068 (E003); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".trust-strip span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0071", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0071", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E003", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, these trust-statistic descriptions share .trust-strip span and the same computed color/size. One local description-color repair covers this group; no cross-tool merging or general contrast verdict is implied." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/CarGurus, the same trust-strip caption component and matching computed foreground tie these instances to one local caption-color repair. No cross-tool merging or general-validity finding is implied." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the trust-strip descriptions use the same .trust-strip span color source and actual foreground. They share one local color repair; the corresponding axe findings remain a separate tool group." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".trust-strip span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0071" }, { "errorId": "ST0072", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G045", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0072", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0072", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0072" }, { "errorId": "ST0073", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G046", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0073", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0073", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0073" }, { "errorId": "ST0074", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G046", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0073", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0073 (E004); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card p\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0074", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0074", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E004", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "These WAVE feature-description reports concern the same .feature-card p color source with identical actual color and size. One correction to the repeated field's local color rule addresses the group; replacement contrast is not verified here." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/CarGurus, repeated feature-card descriptions share the actual .feature-card p foreground treatment. One local description-color change covers this same component-level candidate mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE feature-description instances share the concrete .feature-card p foreground declaration and matching computed style. Repairing that description color is one shared component change." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card p\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0074" }, { "errorId": "ST0075", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G046", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0073", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0073 (E004); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card p\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0075", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0075", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E004", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "These WAVE feature-description reports concern the same .feature-card p color source with identical actual color and size. One correction to the repeated field's local color rule addresses the group; replacement contrast is not verified here." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/CarGurus, repeated feature-card descriptions share the actual .feature-card p foreground treatment. One local description-color change covers this same component-level candidate mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE feature-description instances share the concrete .feature-card p foreground declaration and matching computed style. Repairing that description color is one shared component change." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--muted)\", \"file\": \"index-CJqp0JpH.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card p\"}]；目标共享 rgb(104, 125, 140)/16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0075" }, { "errorId": "ST0076", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G047", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0076", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0076", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0076" }, { "errorId": "ST0077", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G047", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0077", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0077", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0077" }, { "errorId": "ST0078", "site": "cargurus", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/01-cargurus/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/01-cargurus/dist", "reviewGroup": "G048", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select is implicitly associated with its enclosing label and AX exposes combobox Make. The reported orphaned-label mechanism is absent." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select is implicitly associated through its enclosing label; AX names the combobox Make. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not occur." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select is implicitly associated with its enclosing Make label, and AX confirms the combobox name Make. The claimed orphaned-label naming mechanism does not occur." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The select is implicitly associated with its enclosing label and AX exposes combobox Make. The reported orphaned-label mechanism is absent. | B: The select is implicitly associated through its enclosing label; AX names the combobox Make. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not occur. | C: The select is implicitly associated with its enclosing Make label, and AX confirms the combobox name Make. The claimed orphaned-label naming mechanism does not occur.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0078", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0078", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0078" }, { "errorId": "ST0079", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "alt_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G049", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0083", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX repeats each complete product name in a linked image and the nearby separate product-title link. Inferred consequence: sequential screen-reader navigation repeats the same product identification/action. The alt also names its current image-only link, so the repair must preserve a named link while consolidating the structure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each image is the sole naming content of a separate product-image link, so its product alt text meaningfully names that link. Repetition comes from separate cover/title links, adjudicated in G051; removing this alt alone would remove a useful link name." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each image link has the full product name and is followed by a separate identically named product-title link in the same card. AX supports repeated product-name exposure caused by this cover/title structure. The SR repetition is inferred; fixing it must preserve a usable name for the resulting link." } ], "majorityCount": 2, "unanimous": false, "note": "Duplicate of ST0083 (P10; Amazon three alt_redundant candidates and G051 links arise from same shared two-link product card; combine card into one named link with non-redundant image alternative. Base majority: A: AX repeats each complete product name in a linked image and the nearby separate product-title link. Inferred consequence: sequential screen-reader navigation repeats the same product identification/action. The alt also names its current image-only link, so the repair must preserve a named link while consolidating the structure. | C: Each image link has the full product name and is followed by a separate identically named product-title link in the same card. AX supports repeated product-name exposure caused by this cover/title structure. The SR repetition is inferred; fixing it must preserve a usable name for the resulting link.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0079", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0079", "duplicateProposal": "P10", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The repeated image alternatives and the duplicated product-title links are the same two-link product structure established in the Amazon map and AX. Consolidating into one named product link and suppressing the now-redundant image alternative repairs both reports together; simply removing the current image alt would not be an adequate repair." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": false, "reason": "G049's image alt meaningfully names a separate image link, whereas G051 reports the duplicate link structure. A redesign can alter both, but that does not make necessary existing alt text a true instance of the duplicate-link defect; the base decisions differ." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The image-alt repetition and repeated product-title link reports concern the same three Amazon cover/title structures confirmed by DOM and AX. Consolidating each into one named product-opening link and suppressing duplicated image text in that structure resolves both reports through the same shared constructor repair; this is not a site-wide or rule-name association." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0079" }, { "errorId": "ST0080", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "alt_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G049", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0083", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX repeats each complete product name in a linked image and the nearby separate product-title link. Inferred consequence: sequential screen-reader navigation repeats the same product identification/action. The alt also names its current image-only link, so the repair must preserve a named link while consolidating the structure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each image is the sole naming content of a separate product-image link, so its product alt text meaningfully names that link. Repetition comes from separate cover/title links, adjudicated in G051; removing this alt alone would remove a useful link name." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each image link has the full product name and is followed by a separate identically named product-title link in the same card. AX supports repeated product-name exposure caused by this cover/title structure. The SR repetition is inferred; fixing it must preserve a usable name for the resulting link." } ], "majorityCount": 2, "unanimous": false, "note": "Duplicate of ST0083 (P10; Amazon three alt_redundant candidates and G051 links arise from same shared two-link product card; combine card into one named link with non-redundant image alternative. Base majority: A: AX repeats each complete product name in a linked image and the nearby separate product-title link. Inferred consequence: sequential screen-reader navigation repeats the same product identification/action. The alt also names its current image-only link, so the repair must preserve a named link while consolidating the structure. | C: Each image link has the full product name and is followed by a separate identically named product-title link in the same card. AX supports repeated product-name exposure caused by this cover/title structure. The SR repetition is inferred; fixing it must preserve a usable name for the resulting link.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0080", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0080", "duplicateProposal": "P10", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The repeated image alternatives and the duplicated product-title links are the same two-link product structure established in the Amazon map and AX. Consolidating into one named product link and suppressing the now-redundant image alternative repairs both reports together; simply removing the current image alt would not be an adequate repair." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": false, "reason": "G049's image alt meaningfully names a separate image link, whereas G051 reports the duplicate link structure. A redesign can alter both, but that does not make necessary existing alt text a true instance of the duplicate-link defect; the base decisions differ." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The image-alt repetition and repeated product-title link reports concern the same three Amazon cover/title structures confirmed by DOM and AX. Consolidating each into one named product-opening link and suppressing duplicated image text in that structure resolves both reports through the same shared constructor repair; this is not a site-wide or rule-name association." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0080" }, { "errorId": "ST0081", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "alt_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G049", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0083", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX repeats each complete product name in a linked image and the nearby separate product-title link. Inferred consequence: sequential screen-reader navigation repeats the same product identification/action. The alt also names its current image-only link, so the repair must preserve a named link while consolidating the structure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each image is the sole naming content of a separate product-image link, so its product alt text meaningfully names that link. Repetition comes from separate cover/title links, adjudicated in G051; removing this alt alone would remove a useful link name." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each image link has the full product name and is followed by a separate identically named product-title link in the same card. AX supports repeated product-name exposure caused by this cover/title structure. The SR repetition is inferred; fixing it must preserve a usable name for the resulting link." } ], "majorityCount": 2, "unanimous": false, "note": "Duplicate of ST0083 (P10; Amazon three alt_redundant candidates and G051 links arise from same shared two-link product card; combine card into one named link with non-redundant image alternative. Base majority: A: AX repeats each complete product name in a linked image and the nearby separate product-title link. Inferred consequence: sequential screen-reader navigation repeats the same product identification/action. The alt also names its current image-only link, so the repair must preserve a named link while consolidating the structure. | C: Each image link has the full product name and is followed by a separate identically named product-title link in the same card. AX supports repeated product-name exposure caused by this cover/title structure. The SR repetition is inferred; fixing it must preserve a usable name for the resulting link.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0081", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0081", "duplicateProposal": "P10", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The repeated image alternatives and the duplicated product-title links are the same two-link product structure established in the Amazon map and AX. Consolidating into one named product link and suppressing the now-redundant image alternative repairs both reports together; simply removing the current image alt would not be an adequate repair." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": false, "reason": "G049's image alt meaningfully names a separate image link, whereas G051 reports the duplicate link structure. A redesign can alter both, but that does not make necessary existing alt text a true instance of the duplicate-link defect; the base decisions differ." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The image-alt repetition and repeated product-title link reports concern the same three Amazon cover/title structures confirmed by DOM and AX. Consolidating each into one named product-opening link and suppressing duplicated image text in that structure resolves both reports through the same shared constructor repair; this is not a site-wide or rule-name association." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0081" }, { "errorId": "ST0082", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G050", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Explore all is the entry from the Deals worth a look section; the other deals link belongs to a preceding section. Same URL does not show a duplicate adjacent stop serving no distinct navigation context." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Explore all is the entry for Deals worth a look, while See all deals belongs to a different section. Reusing the destination supplies contextual navigation rather than a redundant same-card stop." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Explore all is the action for the Deals worth a look section; See all deals belongs to a different preceding section. The shared URL does not establish redundant stops within the same local task component." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Explore all is the entry from the Deals worth a look section; the other deals link belongs to a preceding section. Same URL does not show a duplicate adjacent stop serving no distinct navigation context. | B: Explore all is the entry for Deals worth a look, while See all deals belongs to a different section. Reusing the destination supplies contextual navigation rather than a redundant same-card stop. | C: Explore all is the action for the Deals worth a look section; See all deals belongs to a different preceding section. The shared URL does not establish redundant stops within the same local task component.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0082", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0082", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0082" }, { "errorId": "ST0083", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G051", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX and source show two nearby links with the same full product name and URL inside each card, separated only by a discount badge. Inferred consequence: repeated product stops in sequential keyboard/screen-reader navigation." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows two separately exposed links with the same full product name and destination within each product card. Inferred: repeated sequential link stops for the same card action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows two separate identically named links to each product within its card, separated only by the badge. This structure introduces an extra product-opening keyboard stop and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AX and source show two nearby links with the same full product name and URL inside each card, separated only by a discount badge. Inferred consequence: repeated product stops in sequential keyboard/screen-reader navigation. | B: AX shows two separately exposed links with the same full product name and destination within each product card. Inferred: repeated sequential link stops for the same card action. | C: AX shows two separate identically named links to each product within its card, separated only by the badge. This structure introduces an extra product-opening keyboard stop and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0083", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0083", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0083" }, { "errorId": "ST0084", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G051", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0083", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX and source show two nearby links with the same full product name and URL inside each card, separated only by a discount badge. Inferred consequence: repeated product stops in sequential keyboard/screen-reader navigation." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows two separately exposed links with the same full product name and destination within each product card. Inferred: repeated sequential link stops for the same card action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows two separate identically named links to each product within its card, separated only by the badge. This structure introduces an extra product-opening keyboard stop and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0083 (P04; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX and source show two nearby links with the same full product name and URL inside each card, separated only by a discount badge. Inferred consequence: repeated product stops in sequential keyboard/screen-reader navigation. | B: AX shows two separately exposed links with the same full product name and destination within each product card. Inferred: repeated sequential link stops for the same card action. | C: AX shows two separate identically named links to each product within its card, separated only by the badge. This structure introduces an extra product-opening keyboard stop and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0084", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0084", "duplicateProposal": "P04", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The same home-product-grid map emits both full-name product links for all three items. Consolidating that exact link structure is one source repair for the repeated-stop findings, not a grouping based only on product-card similarity." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied shared map emits the same image and product-name links for all three Amazon products. One link-structure change in that map fixes the three equivalent card defects." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The one supplied Amazon product-map constructor creates both the fully named image link and same-product title link in all three cards. A shared constructor repair eliminates their repeated product-opening stops." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0084" }, { "errorId": "ST0085", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G051", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0083", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX and source show two nearby links with the same full product name and URL inside each card, separated only by a discount badge. Inferred consequence: repeated product stops in sequential keyboard/screen-reader navigation." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows two separately exposed links with the same full product name and destination within each product card. Inferred: repeated sequential link stops for the same card action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows two separate identically named links to each product within its card, separated only by the badge. This structure introduces an extra product-opening keyboard stop and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0083 (P04; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX and source show two nearby links with the same full product name and URL inside each card, separated only by a discount badge. Inferred consequence: repeated product stops in sequential keyboard/screen-reader navigation. | B: AX shows two separately exposed links with the same full product name and destination within each product card. Inferred: repeated sequential link stops for the same card action. | C: AX shows two separate identically named links to each product within its card, separated only by the badge. This structure introduces an extra product-opening keyboard stop and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0085", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0085", "duplicateProposal": "P04", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The same home-product-grid map emits both full-name product links for all three items. Consolidating that exact link structure is one source repair for the repeated-stop findings, not a grouping based only on product-card similarity." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied shared map emits the same image and product-name links for all three Amazon products. One link-structure change in that map fixes the three equivalent card defects." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The one supplied Amazon product-map constructor creates both the fully named image link and same-product title link in all three cards. A shared constructor repair eliminates their repeated product-opening stops." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0085" }, { "errorId": "ST0086", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G052", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0086", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0086", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0086" }, { "errorId": "ST0087", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G053", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0087", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0087", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0087" }, { "errorId": "ST0088", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G053", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0088", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0088", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0088" }, { "errorId": "ST0089", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G053", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0089", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0089", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0089" }, { "errorId": "ST0090", "site": "amazon", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/02-amazon/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/02-amazon/dist", "reviewGroup": "G053", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0090", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0090", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0090" }, { "errorId": "ST0091", "site": "apple", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/03-apple/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/03-apple/dist", "reviewGroup": "G054", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0091", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0091", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0091" }, { "errorId": "ST0092", "site": "apple", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "heading_possible", "rawRef": "scans/03-apple/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/03-apple/dist", "reviewGroup": "G055", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Just $99 is a price paragraph under the existing h2 Big sound. Small speaker. It is not a missing section heading, and heading navigation already identifies the product feature." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Just $99 is a price paragraph beneath the existing h2 Big sound. Small speaker.; it does not introduce a section needing heading navigation." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Just $99 is a price paragraph under the existing h2 Big sound. Small speaker. It does not introduce a new section, so promoting it to a heading is not needed for SR heading navigation." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Just $99 is a price paragraph under the existing h2 Big sound. Small speaker. It is not a missing section heading, and heading navigation already identifies the product feature. | B: Just $99 is a price paragraph beneath the existing h2 Big sound. Small speaker.; it does not introduce a section needing heading navigation. | C: Just $99 is a price paragraph under the existing h2 Big sound. Small speaker. It does not introduce a new section, so promoting it to a heading is not needed for SR heading navigation.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0092", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0092", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0092" }, { "errorId": "ST0093", "site": "apple", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/03-apple/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/03-apple/dist", "reviewGroup": "G056", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "AppleSupport and Privacy & support have distinct footer labels and contextual roles, separated by copyright. Shared /support alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation or prove a destination-content defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Apple Support and Privacy & support have different contextual purposes separated by footer content. URL reuse alone does not establish a redundant navigation stop; destination-content correctness is untested." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The footer's Apple Support and Privacy & support entries have distinct contextual labels with intervening copyright content. A shared support URL alone does not demonstrate a duplicated adjacent keyboard/SR stop; destination correctness is not evidenced here." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AppleSupport and Privacy & support have distinct footer labels and contextual roles, separated by copyright. Shared /support alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation or prove a destination-content defect. | B: Apple Support and Privacy & support have different contextual purposes separated by footer content. URL reuse alone does not establish a redundant navigation stop; destination-content correctness is untested. | C: The footer's Apple Support and Privacy & support entries have distinct contextual labels with intervening copyright content. A shared support URL alone does not demonstrate a duplicated adjacent keyboard/SR stop; destination correctness is not evidenced here.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0093", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0093", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0093" }, { "errorId": "ST0098", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G060", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0098", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0098", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0098" }, { "errorId": "ST0099", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G061", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0099", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0099", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0099" }, { "errorId": "ST0100", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G061", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0099", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0099 (E006); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(130, 125, 120)\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".price-original\"}]；目标共享 rgb(130, 125, 120)/13.12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0100", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0100", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E006", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price candidates share the .price-original declaration and identical computed color/size. A single local original-price color correction addresses both; this is independent of the axe group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Both WAVE candidates are repeated original-price fields using the same active .price-original color treatment. This is one local field-style repair within the same tool and site." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price candidates have the same .price-original declaration and computed foreground. One local original-price color change covers these two instances, independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(130, 125, 120)\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".price-original\"}]；目标共享 rgb(130, 125, 120)/13.12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0100" }, { "errorId": "ST0101", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G062", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes image/product-name/View Details links to the identical product inside each card. Inferred consequence: keyboard and screen-reader link traversal repeat the same product action before Add to Bag." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes cover/View details, product-name, and another View Details link to the same product in one card. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same product action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each AX product card exposes the product-opening image link, product-title link and View Details link. The title repeats an already exposed product destination within that card, adding keyboard traversal and SR repetition; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AX exposes image/product-name/View Details links to the identical product inside each card. Inferred consequence: keyboard and screen-reader link traversal repeat the same product action before Add to Bag. | B: AX exposes cover/View details, product-name, and another View Details link to the same product in one card. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same product action. | C: Each AX product card exposes the product-opening image link, product-title link and View Details link. The title repeats an already exposed product destination within that card, adding keyboard traversal and SR repetition; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0101", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0101", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0101" }, { "errorId": "ST0102", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G063", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0101", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The card's View Details link repeats its already exposed product image and title links to the same product. Inferred consequence: another equivalent navigation stop before Add to Bag, supported by AX and the shared card source." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The final View Details link repeats the already exposed cover and product-title action within the same card. Inferred: an additional redundant sequential link stop." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each View Details link is AX-exposed after image and title links to the same product within one card. It adds another stop for the same product-opening action; inferred from the recorded AX structure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0101 (P11; The same Macy's qo product-card constructor emits cover, title and View Details links to one product. Consolidate the three product links into one named link while preserving the independent Add to Bag button; source evidence in P05. Base majority: A: The card's View Details link repeats its already exposed product image and title links to the same product. Inferred consequence: another equivalent navigation stop before Add to Bag, supported by AX and the shared card source. | B: The final View Details link repeats the already exposed cover and product-title action within the same card. Inferred: an additional redundant sequential link stop. | C: Each View Details link is AX-exposed after image and title links to the same product within one card. It adds another stop for the same product-opening action; inferred from the recorded AX structure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0102", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0102", "duplicateProposal": "P11", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The same qo constructor produces all three AX-exposed links to each product: cover, title and View Details. G062 and G063 therefore report parts of the same repeated product-navigation structure. Consolidating these into one named product link while retaining the independent Add to Bag button is one concrete source repair for ST0101, ST0102 and ST0104; the navigation consequence is inferred from source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared qo constructor exposes cover, title and bottom View Details links to the same product, confirmed in AX for both cards. G062 and G063 are manifestations of that one three-link structure; one constructor-level named-product-link repair resolves all three while retaining the separate Add to Bag action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied qo constructor and AX show that the bottom View Details links and the G062 title links participate in the same three exposed product-opening links per card. Consolidating this shared constructor into one named product link while preserving the independent Add to Bag button resolves all these repeated stops with the same structural repair. The relation is supported by the concrete shared constructor and compatible base decisions, not merely by the site or rule category." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0102" }, { "errorId": "ST0103", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G062", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0101", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes image/product-name/View Details links to the identical product inside each card. Inferred consequence: keyboard and screen-reader link traversal repeat the same product action before Add to Bag." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes cover/View details, product-name, and another View Details link to the same product in one card. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same product action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each AX product card exposes the product-opening image link, product-title link and View Details link. The title repeats an already exposed product destination within that card, adding keyboard traversal and SR repetition; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0101 (P05; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX exposes image/product-name/View Details links to the identical product inside each card. Inferred consequence: keyboard and screen-reader link traversal repeat the same product action before Add to Bag. | B: AX exposes cover/View details, product-name, and another View Details link to the same product in one card. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same product action. | C: Each AX product card exposes the product-opening image link, product-title link and View Details link. The title repeats an already exposed product destination within that card, adding keyboard traversal and SR repetition; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0103", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0103", "duplicateProposal": "P05", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both products use qo, which emits image, title and View Details links to one product. Reducing that repeated destination structure is one concrete shared repair. G063 describes the third link from the same constructor and is also implicated in that same repair, though its base votes remain explicit." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Both products use qo with the same three equivalent product links. One shared card link-structure repair fixes G062; G063 ST0102 and ST0104 are additional manifestations of that same three-link defect and can share this canonical finding because their base decisions are also correct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The qo constructor supplies the cover, title and View Details links to the same product for both Macy's instances. Consolidating this card's product-opening links is one structural repair. G063 ST0102 and ST0104 arise from that same confirmed AX-exposed three-link structure and can also share this repair when their base decisions agree." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0103" }, { "errorId": "ST0104", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G063", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0101", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The card's View Details link repeats its already exposed product image and title links to the same product. Inferred consequence: another equivalent navigation stop before Add to Bag, supported by AX and the shared card source." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The final View Details link repeats the already exposed cover and product-title action within the same card. Inferred: an additional redundant sequential link stop." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each View Details link is AX-exposed after image and title links to the same product within one card. It adds another stop for the same product-opening action; inferred from the recorded AX structure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0101 (P11; The same Macy's qo product-card constructor emits cover, title and View Details links to one product. Consolidate the three product links into one named link while preserving the independent Add to Bag button; source evidence in P05. Base majority: A: The card's View Details link repeats its already exposed product image and title links to the same product. Inferred consequence: another equivalent navigation stop before Add to Bag, supported by AX and the shared card source. | B: The final View Details link repeats the already exposed cover and product-title action within the same card. Inferred: an additional redundant sequential link stop. | C: Each View Details link is AX-exposed after image and title links to the same product within one card. It adds another stop for the same product-opening action; inferred from the recorded AX structure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0104", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0104", "duplicateProposal": "P11", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The same qo constructor produces all three AX-exposed links to each product: cover, title and View Details. G062 and G063 therefore report parts of the same repeated product-navigation structure. Consolidating these into one named product link while retaining the independent Add to Bag button is one concrete source repair for ST0101, ST0102 and ST0104; the navigation consequence is inferred from source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared qo constructor exposes cover, title and bottom View Details links to the same product, confirmed in AX for both cards. G062 and G063 are manifestations of that one three-link structure; one constructor-level named-product-link repair resolves all three while retaining the separate Add to Bag action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied qo constructor and AX show that the bottom View Details links and the G062 title links participate in the same three exposed product-opening links per card. Consolidating this shared constructor into one named product link while preserving the independent Add to Bag button resolves all these repeated stops with the same structural repair. The relation is supported by the concrete shared constructor and compatible base decisions, not merely by the site or rule category." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0104" }, { "errorId": "ST0105", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G064", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0105", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0105", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0105" }, { "errorId": "ST0106", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G064", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0105", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0105 (E033); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-tile span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(23, 23, 23)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0106", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0106", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E033", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The feature-tile captions all use .feature-tile span at actual 10.72px from 0.67rem. Increasing this one local feature-caption font-size addresses the same reported mechanism across the repeated tiles." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The candidates are repeated feature-tile captions with the same active .feature-tile span size of 10.72px. One local feature-caption font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The feature-tile labels share .feature-tile span font-size and the actual 10.72px size. One change to that tile-label size declaration addresses all instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-tile span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(23, 23, 23)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0106" }, { "errorId": "ST0107", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G064", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0105", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0105 (E033); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-tile span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(23, 23, 23)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0107", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0107", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E033", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The feature-tile captions all use .feature-tile span at actual 10.72px from 0.67rem. Increasing this one local feature-caption font-size addresses the same reported mechanism across the repeated tiles." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The candidates are repeated feature-tile captions with the same active .feature-tile span size of 10.72px. One local feature-caption font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The feature-tile labels share .feature-tile span font-size and the actual 10.72px size. One change to that tile-label size declaration addresses all instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-tile span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(23, 23, 23)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0107" }, { "errorId": "ST0108", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G064", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0105", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0105 (E033); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-tile span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(23, 23, 23)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0108", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0108", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E033", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The feature-tile captions all use .feature-tile span at actual 10.72px from 0.67rem. Increasing this one local feature-caption font-size addresses the same reported mechanism across the repeated tiles." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The candidates are repeated feature-tile captions with the same active .feature-tile span size of 10.72px. One local feature-caption font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The feature-tile labels share .feature-tile span font-size and the actual 10.72px size. One change to that tile-label size declaration addresses all instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.67rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-tile span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(23, 23, 23)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0108" }, { "errorId": "ST0109", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G065", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0109", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0109", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0109" }, { "errorId": "ST0110", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G066", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0110", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0110", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0110" }, { "errorId": "ST0111", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G067", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0111", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0111", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0111" }, { "errorId": "ST0112", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G068", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0112", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0112", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0112" }, { "errorId": "ST0113", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G065", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0113", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0113", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0113" }, { "errorId": "ST0114", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G066", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0114", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0114", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0114" }, { "errorId": "ST0115", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G067", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0111", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0111 (E034); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.65rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".price-save\"}]；目标共享 rgb(211, 19, 42)/10.4px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0115", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0115", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E034", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The percentage-savings texts share .price-save and actual 10.4px from 0.65rem. One local savings-field font-size change covers both percentages." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Both values are product-saving percentages styled by .price-save at an actual 10.4px. One savings-field font-size change covers both repeated instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both savings percentages use .price-save and its computed 10.4px size. Repairing that savings-caption font-size is one common local change." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.65rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".price-save\"}]；目标共享 rgb(211, 19, 42)/10.4px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0115" }, { "errorId": "ST0116", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G068", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0112", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0112 (E035); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".product-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(102, 97, 93)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0116", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0116", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E035", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The product color metadata fields share .product-meta with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. Their different color words do not change the concrete common repair: adjust that field's local font size." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Both candidates are product color metadata styled by .product-meta at an actual 10.88px. One local product-metadata font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both product color metadata fields share .product-meta and the computed 10.88px size. A single product-metadata size repair covers the pair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-1Ei0oUn_.css\", \"selector\": \".product-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(102, 97, 93)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0116" }, { "errorId": "ST0117", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G069", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0117", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0117", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0117" }, { "errorId": "ST0118", "site": "macys", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/04-macys/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/04-macys/dist", "reviewGroup": "G070", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0118", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0118", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0118" }, { "errorId": "ST0137", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G079", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0137", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0137", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0137" }, { "errorId": "ST0138", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G080", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0138", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0138", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0138" }, { "errorId": "ST0139", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G081", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0139", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0139", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0139" }, { "errorId": "ST0140", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G079", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0137", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0137 (E008); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0140", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0140", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E008", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE the repeated category fields share .product-category and the same computed color/size. Correcting that specific category-field color once covers these reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE candidates repeat the same product-category field with the same computed foreground from .product-category. One local category-caption color adjustment addresses this shared mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE category fields share the concrete .product-category color declaration and matching computed style. Their relation is a common component-field repair, not simply equal colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0140" }, { "errorId": "ST0141", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G080", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0138", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0138 (E010); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(136, 136, 136)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".rating span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 136, 136)/11.52px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0141", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0141", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E010", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE rating counts instantiate the same .rating span color rule with equal computed color and size. One local rating-count color correction addresses the group, independent of axe reporting." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, all candidates are review-count spans with the same active local rating-count color treatment. Their counts differ, but the component-level repair is common." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE review-count candidates use the same .rating span declaration with matching actual styling. One rating-count color repair covers the group." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(136, 136, 136)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".rating span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 136, 136)/11.52px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0141" }, { "errorId": "ST0142", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G081", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0139", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0139 (E012); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".swatches span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/11.2px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0142", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0142", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E012", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE swatch-name labels share the specific .swatches span declaration and computed text treatment. One local label-color repair covers these repeated field instances, without treating their differently named colors as different defects." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Uniqlo, repeated swatch text labels share the active local .swatches span foreground. The proposed relationship follows the same component role and repair rather than the names of the colors." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, all listed color labels use .swatches span with the same applied foreground. The exact shared label-style declaration supports one repair relation." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".swatches span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/11.2px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0142" }, { "errorId": "ST0143", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G079", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0137", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0137 (E008); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0143", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0143", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E008", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE the repeated category fields share .product-category and the same computed color/size. Correcting that specific category-field color once covers these reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE candidates repeat the same product-category field with the same computed foreground from .product-category. One local category-caption color adjustment addresses this shared mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE category fields share the concrete .product-category color declaration and matching computed style. Their relation is a common component-field repair, not simply equal colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0143" }, { "errorId": "ST0144", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G080", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0138", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0138 (E010); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(136, 136, 136)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".rating span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 136, 136)/11.52px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0144", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0144", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E010", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE rating counts instantiate the same .rating span color rule with equal computed color and size. One local rating-count color correction addresses the group, independent of axe reporting." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, all candidates are review-count spans with the same active local rating-count color treatment. Their counts differ, but the component-level repair is common." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE review-count candidates use the same .rating span declaration with matching actual styling. One rating-count color repair covers the group." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(136, 136, 136)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".rating span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 136, 136)/11.52px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0144" }, { "errorId": "ST0145", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G081", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0139", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0139 (E012); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".swatches span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/11.2px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0145", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0145", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E012", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE swatch-name labels share the specific .swatches span declaration and computed text treatment. One local label-color repair covers these repeated field instances, without treating their differently named colors as different defects." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Uniqlo, repeated swatch text labels share the active local .swatches span foreground. The proposed relationship follows the same component role and repair rather than the names of the colors." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, all listed color labels use .swatches span with the same applied foreground. The exact shared label-style declaration supports one repair relation." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".swatches span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/11.2px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0145" }, { "errorId": "ST0146", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G079", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0137", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0137 (E008); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0146", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0146", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E008", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE the repeated category fields share .product-category and the same computed color/size. Correcting that specific category-field color once covers these reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE candidates repeat the same product-category field with the same computed foreground from .product-category. One local category-caption color adjustment addresses this shared mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE category fields share the concrete .product-category color declaration and matching computed style. Their relation is a common component-field repair, not simply equal colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0146" }, { "errorId": "ST0147", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G080", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0138", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0138 (E010); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(136, 136, 136)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".rating span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 136, 136)/11.52px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0147", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0147", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E010", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE rating counts instantiate the same .rating span color rule with equal computed color and size. One local rating-count color correction addresses the group, independent of axe reporting." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, all candidates are review-count spans with the same active local rating-count color treatment. Their counts differ, but the component-level repair is common." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE review-count candidates use the same .rating span declaration with matching actual styling. One rating-count color repair covers the group." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(136, 136, 136)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".rating span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 136, 136)/11.52px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0147" }, { "errorId": "ST0148", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G082", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0148", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0148", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0148" }, { "errorId": "ST0149", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G081", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0139", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0139 (E012); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".swatches span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/11.2px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0149", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0149", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E012", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE swatch-name labels share the specific .swatches span declaration and computed text treatment. One local label-color repair covers these repeated field instances, without treating their differently named colors as different defects." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Uniqlo, repeated swatch text labels share the active local .swatches span foreground. The proposed relationship follows the same component role and repair rather than the names of the colors." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, all listed color labels use .swatches span with the same applied foreground. The exact shared label-style declaration supports one repair relation." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(119, 119, 119)\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".swatches span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/11.2px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0149" }, { "errorId": "ST0150", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G083", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0150", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0150", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0150" }, { "errorId": "ST0151", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G084", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0151", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0151", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0151" }, { "errorId": "ST0152", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G085", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0152", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0152", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0152" }, { "errorId": "ST0153", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G085", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0153", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0153", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0153" }, { "errorId": "ST0154", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0154", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0154", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0154" }, { "errorId": "ST0155", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0155", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0155", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0155" }, { "errorId": "ST0156", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0156", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0156", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0156" }, { "errorId": "ST0157", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0157", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0157", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0157" }, { "errorId": "ST0158", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0158", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0158", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0158" }, { "errorId": "ST0159", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0159", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0159", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0159" }, { "errorId": "ST0160", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0160", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0160", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0160" }, { "errorId": "ST0161", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G086", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each select is inside its label and all eight AX names explicitly identify Size or Quantity plus the product. There is no orphaned-label or missing-control-name consequence. | B: The selects are nested within labels and AX supplies distinct Size for product and Quantity for product names for all eight controls. No orphaned or unnamed control is demonstrated. | C: Each select is inside its label and additionally has a product-specific aria-label. AX confirms all eight Size/Quantity names, so the reported orphaned-label naming failure is absent.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0161", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0161", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0161" }, { "errorId": "ST0162", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0162", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0162", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0162" }, { "errorId": "ST0163", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0163", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0163", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0163" }, { "errorId": "ST0164", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G088", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0164", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0164", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0164" }, { "errorId": "ST0165", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G088", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0165", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0165", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0165" }, { "errorId": "ST0166", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G089", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0166", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0166", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0166" }, { "errorId": "ST0167", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G090", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0167", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0167", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0167" }, { "errorId": "ST0168", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0168", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0168", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0168" }, { "errorId": "ST0169", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0169", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0169", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0169" }, { "errorId": "ST0170", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G089", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0166", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0166 (E036); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0170", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0170", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E036", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The product badges share .product-badge, actual 10.24px and the same white-on-dark treatment. One correction to the 0.64rem badge font-size declaration addresses all three reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These are product badges sharing .product-badge and the same actual 10.24px size with the same foreground/background treatment. One badge font-size adjustment covers the instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The product badges share .product-badge with an actual 10.24px font size. Repairing this badge-size declaration once covers the repeated labels." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0170" }, { "errorId": "ST0171", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G090", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0167", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0167 (E037); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0171", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0171", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E037", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The category descriptions share .product-category and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. Adjusting that specific field's font-size once addresses the small-text mechanism across the products; this is not merged with contrast findings." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The product-category fields all use the same active .product-category size of 10.88px. One local category-caption font-size repair covers the same repeated field regardless of category text." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The product-category fields share .product-category and the actual 10.88px font size. One category-field size repair addresses these text_small instances; contrast remains a different mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0171" }, { "errorId": "ST0172", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0172", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0172", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0172" }, { "errorId": "ST0173", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0173", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0173", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0173" }, { "errorId": "ST0174", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G089", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0166", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0166 (E036); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0174", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0174", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E036", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The product badges share .product-badge, actual 10.24px and the same white-on-dark treatment. One correction to the 0.64rem badge font-size declaration addresses all three reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These are product badges sharing .product-badge and the same actual 10.24px size with the same foreground/background treatment. One badge font-size adjustment covers the instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The product badges share .product-badge with an actual 10.24px font size. Repairing this badge-size declaration once covers the repeated labels." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0174" }, { "errorId": "ST0175", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G090", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0167", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0167 (E037); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0175", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0175", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E037", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The category descriptions share .product-category and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. Adjusting that specific field's font-size once addresses the small-text mechanism across the products; this is not merged with contrast findings." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The product-category fields all use the same active .product-category size of 10.88px. One local category-caption font-size repair covers the same repeated field regardless of category text." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The product-category fields share .product-category and the actual 10.88px font size. One category-field size repair addresses these text_small instances; contrast remains a different mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0175" }, { "errorId": "ST0176", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0176", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0176", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0176" }, { "errorId": "ST0177", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0177", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0177", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0177" }, { "errorId": "ST0178", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G091", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0178", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0178", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0178" }, { "errorId": "ST0179", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G090", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0167", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0167 (E037); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0179", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0179", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E037", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The category descriptions share .product-category and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. Adjusting that specific field's font-size once addresses the small-text mechanism across the products; this is not merged with contrast findings." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The product-category fields all use the same active .product-category size of 10.88px. One local category-caption font-size repair covers the same repeated field regardless of category text." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The product-category fields share .product-category and the actual 10.88px font size. One category-field size repair addresses these text_small instances; contrast remains a different mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CDnoI4AK.css\", \"selector\": \".product-category\"}]；目标共享 rgb(119, 119, 119)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0179" }, { "errorId": "ST0180", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0180", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0180", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0180" }, { "errorId": "ST0181", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G087", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0181", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0181", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0181" }, { "errorId": "ST0182", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G092", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0182", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0182", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0182" }, { "errorId": "ST0183", "site": "uniqlo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/05-uniqlo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/05-uniqlo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G092", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0183", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0183", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0183" }, { "errorId": "ST0190", "site": "flightaware", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/06-flightaware/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/06-flightaware/dist", "reviewGroup": "G098", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0190", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0190", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0190" }, { "errorId": "ST0191", "site": "flightaware", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/06-flightaware/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/06-flightaware/dist", "reviewGroup": "G099", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0191", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0191", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0191" }, { "errorId": "ST0192", "site": "flightaware", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/06-flightaware/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/06-flightaware/dist", "reviewGroup": "G100", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0192", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0192", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0192" }, { "errorId": "ST0193", "site": "flightaware", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/06-flightaware/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/06-flightaware/dist", "reviewGroup": "G101", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0193", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0193", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0193" }, { "errorId": "ST0194", "site": "flightaware", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/06-flightaware/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/06-flightaware/dist", "reviewGroup": "G101", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0193", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0193 (E014); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(0, 139, 185)\", \"file\": \"index-CxkHqXh4.css\", \"selector\": \".text-link, .card-link\"}]；目标共享 rgb(0, 139, 185)/16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0194", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0194", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E014", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both WAVE links share the combined .text-link, .card-link declaration and the same actual color and size. The shared local link-color treatment provides the same-source repair relationship; general contrast validity remains unadjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/FlightAware, these two link labels use the same combined local link-color declaration and matching actual computed foreground. One shared textual-link foreground repair covers this candidate treatment; general validity is not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The two WAVE links share one concrete combined-selector link-color declaration and the same computed foreground. This supports a single source color repair despite their different link labels." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(0, 139, 185)\", \"file\": \"index-CxkHqXh4.css\", \"selector\": \".text-link, .card-link\"}]；目标共享 rgb(0, 139, 185)/16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0194" }, { "errorId": "ST0195", "site": "flightaware", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/06-flightaware/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/06-flightaware/dist", "reviewGroup": "G102", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0195", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0195", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0195" }, { "errorId": "ST0196", "site": "aa", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/07-aa/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/07-aa/dist", "reviewGroup": "G103", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosing labels supply native associations and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not hold." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is implicitly labelled by its enclosing label and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported label association failure is absent." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Adults, Children and Cabin selects are implicitly labeled by their enclosing labels; AX confirms these names. A missing for attribute does not make these labels orphaned." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The enclosing labels supply native associations and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not hold. | B: Each select is implicitly labelled by its enclosing label and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported label association failure is absent. | C: Adults, Children and Cabin selects are implicitly labeled by their enclosing labels; AX confirms these names. A missing for attribute does not make these labels orphaned.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0196", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0196", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0196" }, { "errorId": "ST0197", "site": "aa", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/07-aa/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/07-aa/dist", "reviewGroup": "G103", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosing labels supply native associations and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not hold." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is implicitly labelled by its enclosing label and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported label association failure is absent." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Adults, Children and Cabin selects are implicitly labeled by their enclosing labels; AX confirms these names. A missing for attribute does not make these labels orphaned." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The enclosing labels supply native associations and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not hold. | B: Each select is implicitly labelled by its enclosing label and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported label association failure is absent. | C: Adults, Children and Cabin selects are implicitly labeled by their enclosing labels; AX confirms these names. A missing for attribute does not make these labels orphaned.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0197", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0197", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0197" }, { "errorId": "ST0198", "site": "aa", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/07-aa/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/07-aa/dist", "reviewGroup": "G103", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosing labels supply native associations and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not hold." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each select is implicitly labelled by its enclosing label and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported label association failure is absent." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Adults, Children and Cabin selects are implicitly labeled by their enclosing labels; AX confirms these names. A missing for attribute does not make these labels orphaned." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The enclosing labels supply native associations and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported orphaned-label mechanism does not hold. | B: Each select is implicitly labelled by its enclosing label and AX exposes Adults, Children (2–11), and Cabin. The reported label association failure is absent. | C: Adults, Children and Cabin selects are implicitly labeled by their enclosing labels; AX confirms these names. A missing for attribute does not make these labels orphaned.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0198", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0198", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0198" }, { "errorId": "ST0199", "site": "aa", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "fieldset_missing", "rawRef": "scans/07-aa/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/07-aa/dist", "reviewGroup": "G104", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The common name tripType provides native radio grouping and AX exposes self-explanatory Round trip, One way, Multi-city and Vacation package choices. No missing group instruction or ambiguity requiring a fieldset is established here." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "AX exposes mutually exclusive, self-explanatory Round trip, One way, Multi-city, and Vacation package radios in the booking context; DOM shares tripType. Missing fieldset alone does not establish lost meaning for these already clear alternatives." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "AX exposes Round trip, One way, Multi-city and Vacation package as explicitly named radios in the booking context; shared tripType supplies native radio grouping. The absent fieldset does not establish missing choice identity or keyboard grouping for these self-explanatory options." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The common name tripType provides native radio grouping and AX exposes self-explanatory Round trip, One way, Multi-city and Vacation package choices. No missing group instruction or ambiguity requiring a fieldset is established here. | B: AX exposes mutually exclusive, self-explanatory Round trip, One way, Multi-city, and Vacation package radios in the booking context; DOM shares tripType. Missing fieldset alone does not establish lost meaning for these already clear alternatives. | C: AX exposes Round trip, One way, Multi-city and Vacation package as explicitly named radios in the booking context; shared tripType supplies native radio grouping. The absent fieldset does not establish missing choice identity or keyboard grouping for these self-explanatory options.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0199", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0199", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0199" }, { "errorId": "ST0200", "site": "aa", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/07-aa/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/07-aa/dist", "reviewGroup": "G105", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0200", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0200", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0200" }, { "errorId": "ST0205", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G110", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0205", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0205", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0205" }, { "errorId": "ST0206", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G111", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes a View-business visual link followed by a heading link to the same business within each card. Inferred consequence: equivalent business stops repeat during sequential link/keyboard traversal." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes View business and the business-name link to the same destination within each business card. Inferred: repeated sequential navigation to the same business action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes View-business and business-title links to the same business within each result card. The repeated business-opening action adds a keyboard stop and repeated SR exposure within a result; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AX exposes a View-business visual link followed by a heading link to the same business within each card. Inferred consequence: equivalent business stops repeat during sequential link/keyboard traversal. | B: AX exposes View business and the business-name link to the same destination within each business card. Inferred: repeated sequential navigation to the same business action. | C: AX exposes View-business and business-title links to the same business within each result card. The repeated business-opening action adds a keyboard stop and repeated SR exposure within a result; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0206", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0206", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0206" }, { "errorId": "ST0207", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G112", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three exact targets the captured DOM records visible=false and zero-size layout, while the complete saved AX omits View details. In this captured homepage state the hidden links do not supply the extra exposed navigation stops reported by link_redundant; source existence alone is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three candidates the recorded DOM has visible=false and a zero-sized rectangle, and the saved full AX exposes no View details link. In the audited homepage state these hidden targets do not add the claimed redundant screen-reader/keyboard navigation stop; their existence in the shared source is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three original candidate records, dom.visible=false and the layout rect is entirely zero; the complete saved AX also contains no View details links. In this scanned initial homepage state these DOM links do not supply the alleged extra exposed keyboard/SR stops. Their source-level existence alone does not establish the reported redundant interaction." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: For all three exact targets the captured DOM records visible=false and zero-size layout, while the complete saved AX omits View details. In this captured homepage state the hidden links do not supply the extra exposed navigation stops reported by link_redundant; source existence alone is insufficient. | B: For all three candidates the recorded DOM has visible=false and a zero-sized rectangle, and the saved full AX exposes no View details link. In the audited homepage state these hidden targets do not add the claimed redundant screen-reader/keyboard navigation stop; their existence in the shared source is insufficient. | C: For all three original candidate records, dom.visible=false and the layout rect is entirely zero; the complete saved AX also contains no View details links. In this scanned initial homepage state these DOM links do not supply the alleged extra exposed keyboard/SR stops. Their source-level existence alone does not establish the reported redundant interaction.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0207", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0207", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0207" }, { "errorId": "ST0208", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G111", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0206", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes a View-business visual link followed by a heading link to the same business within each card. Inferred consequence: equivalent business stops repeat during sequential link/keyboard traversal." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes View business and the business-name link to the same destination within each business card. Inferred: repeated sequential navigation to the same business action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes View-business and business-title links to the same business within each result card. The repeated business-opening action adds a keyboard stop and repeated SR exposure within a result; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0206 (P06; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX exposes a View-business visual link followed by a heading link to the same business within each card. Inferred consequence: equivalent business stops repeat during sequential link/keyboard traversal. | B: AX exposes View business and the business-name link to the same destination within each business card. Inferred: repeated sequential navigation to the same business action. | C: AX exposes View-business and business-title links to the same business within each result card. The repeated business-opening action adds a keyboard stop and repeated SR exposure within a result; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0208", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0208", "duplicateProposal": "P06", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The Tp constructor directly establishes the repeated View-business/title links for all three businesses, so one structural repair covers G111. G112's hidden View details targets have a different base judgment in the captured state and must not be folded into this true repeated-stop group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied Tp constructor creates the same exposed cover/title duplicate for all three businesses. One constructor-level repair covers G111. G112's targets are hidden with zero-sized rectangles and absent from AX in the audited state, so those false-positive candidates must not merge into this correct finding." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied Tp business-card constructor creates the AX-exposed visual and title links in every G111 instance; a single link-structure repair addresses their shared repeated business-opening action. This relation does not extend to G112: the final visibility, zero-layout and AX evidence establishes that those View details targets do not supply the reported extra exposed stops in the scanned initial state, so their base decision differs." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0208" }, { "errorId": "ST0209", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G112", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three exact targets the captured DOM records visible=false and zero-size layout, while the complete saved AX omits View details. In this captured homepage state the hidden links do not supply the extra exposed navigation stops reported by link_redundant; source existence alone is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three candidates the recorded DOM has visible=false and a zero-sized rectangle, and the saved full AX exposes no View details link. In the audited homepage state these hidden targets do not add the claimed redundant screen-reader/keyboard navigation stop; their existence in the shared source is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three original candidate records, dom.visible=false and the layout rect is entirely zero; the complete saved AX also contains no View details links. In this scanned initial homepage state these DOM links do not supply the alleged extra exposed keyboard/SR stops. Their source-level existence alone does not establish the reported redundant interaction." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: For all three exact targets the captured DOM records visible=false and zero-size layout, while the complete saved AX omits View details. In this captured homepage state the hidden links do not supply the extra exposed navigation stops reported by link_redundant; source existence alone is insufficient. | B: For all three candidates the recorded DOM has visible=false and a zero-sized rectangle, and the saved full AX exposes no View details link. In the audited homepage state these hidden targets do not add the claimed redundant screen-reader/keyboard navigation stop; their existence in the shared source is insufficient. | C: For all three original candidate records, dom.visible=false and the layout rect is entirely zero; the complete saved AX also contains no View details links. In this scanned initial homepage state these DOM links do not supply the alleged extra exposed keyboard/SR stops. Their source-level existence alone does not establish the reported redundant interaction.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0209", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0209", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0209" }, { "errorId": "ST0210", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G111", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0206", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes a View-business visual link followed by a heading link to the same business within each card. Inferred consequence: equivalent business stops repeat during sequential link/keyboard traversal." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes View business and the business-name link to the same destination within each business card. Inferred: repeated sequential navigation to the same business action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes View-business and business-title links to the same business within each result card. The repeated business-opening action adds a keyboard stop and repeated SR exposure within a result; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0206 (P06; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX exposes a View-business visual link followed by a heading link to the same business within each card. Inferred consequence: equivalent business stops repeat during sequential link/keyboard traversal. | B: AX exposes View business and the business-name link to the same destination within each business card. Inferred: repeated sequential navigation to the same business action. | C: AX exposes View-business and business-title links to the same business within each result card. The repeated business-opening action adds a keyboard stop and repeated SR exposure within a result; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0210", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0210", "duplicateProposal": "P06", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The Tp constructor directly establishes the repeated View-business/title links for all three businesses, so one structural repair covers G111. G112's hidden View details targets have a different base judgment in the captured state and must not be folded into this true repeated-stop group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied Tp constructor creates the same exposed cover/title duplicate for all three businesses. One constructor-level repair covers G111. G112's targets are hidden with zero-sized rectangles and absent from AX in the audited state, so those false-positive candidates must not merge into this correct finding." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied Tp business-card constructor creates the AX-exposed visual and title links in every G111 instance; a single link-structure repair addresses their shared repeated business-opening action. This relation does not extend to G112: the final visibility, zero-layout and AX evidence establishes that those View details targets do not supply the reported extra exposed stops in the scanned initial state, so their base decision differs." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0210" }, { "errorId": "ST0211", "site": "yelp", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/08-yelp/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/08-yelp/dist", "reviewGroup": "G112", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three exact targets the captured DOM records visible=false and zero-size layout, while the complete saved AX omits View details. In this captured homepage state the hidden links do not supply the extra exposed navigation stops reported by link_redundant; source existence alone is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three candidates the recorded DOM has visible=false and a zero-sized rectangle, and the saved full AX exposes no View details link. In the audited homepage state these hidden targets do not add the claimed redundant screen-reader/keyboard navigation stop; their existence in the shared source is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "For all three original candidate records, dom.visible=false and the layout rect is entirely zero; the complete saved AX also contains no View details links. In this scanned initial homepage state these DOM links do not supply the alleged extra exposed keyboard/SR stops. Their source-level existence alone does not establish the reported redundant interaction." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: For all three exact targets the captured DOM records visible=false and zero-size layout, while the complete saved AX omits View details. In this captured homepage state the hidden links do not supply the extra exposed navigation stops reported by link_redundant; source existence alone is insufficient. | B: For all three candidates the recorded DOM has visible=false and a zero-sized rectangle, and the saved full AX exposes no View details link. In the audited homepage state these hidden targets do not add the claimed redundant screen-reader/keyboard navigation stop; their existence in the shared source is insufficient. | C: For all three original candidate records, dom.visible=false and the layout rect is entirely zero; the complete saved AX also contains no View details links. In this scanned initial homepage state these DOM links do not supply the alleged extra exposed keyboard/SR stops. Their source-level existence alone does not establish the reported redundant interaction.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0211", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0211", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0211" }, { "errorId": "ST0213", "site": "amtrak", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/09-amtrak/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/09-amtrak/dist", "reviewGroup": "G114", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select is nested in a label and AX exposes Service class through its aria-label. No orphaned or unnamed service selector is established." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select is enclosed by its label and has aria-label Service class, confirmed in AX. The alleged orphaned label does not produce an unnamed service selector." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The Service select is enclosed by its label and has aria-label Service class; AX confirms Service class. The claimed orphaned-label naming issue is contradicted by both DOM and AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The select is nested in a label and AX exposes Service class through its aria-label. No orphaned or unnamed service selector is established. | B: The select is enclosed by its label and has aria-label Service class, confirmed in AX. The alleged orphaned label does not produce an unnamed service selector. | C: The Service select is enclosed by its label and has aria-label Service class; AX confirms Service class. The claimed orphaned-label naming issue is contradicted by both DOM and AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0213", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0213", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0213" }, { "errorId": "ST0214", "site": "amtrak", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/09-amtrak/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/09-amtrak/dist", "reviewGroup": "G115", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0214", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0214", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0214" }, { "errorId": "ST0215", "site": "amtrak", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/09-amtrak/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/09-amtrak/dist", "reviewGroup": "G115", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0214", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0214 (E038); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D2ZsA99i.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card > div > span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(0, 117, 169)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0215", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0215", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E038", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The route/vacation feature captions share .feature-card > div > span and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. A local caption-size correction addresses the same repeated field across those feature cards." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These feature-card introductory captions share the specific .feature-card > div > span declaration and computed size of 10.88px. One caption font-size repair covers the repeated feature component." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The route/vacation overlines share the specific .feature-card > div > span size declaration and computed 10.88px. One repair to this card-label size covers all listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D2ZsA99i.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card > div > span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(0, 117, 169)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0215" }, { "errorId": "ST0216", "site": "amtrak", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/09-amtrak/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/09-amtrak/dist", "reviewGroup": "G115", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0214", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0214 (E038); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D2ZsA99i.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card > div > span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(0, 117, 169)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0216", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0216", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E038", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The route/vacation feature captions share .feature-card > div > span and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. A local caption-size correction addresses the same repeated field across those feature cards." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These feature-card introductory captions share the specific .feature-card > div > span declaration and computed size of 10.88px. One caption font-size repair covers the repeated feature component." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The route/vacation overlines share the specific .feature-card > div > span size declaration and computed 10.88px. One repair to this card-label size covers all listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D2ZsA99i.css\", \"selector\": \".feature-card > div > span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(0, 117, 169)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0216" }, { "errorId": "ST0217", "site": "expedia", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/10-expedia/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/10-expedia/dist", "reviewGroup": "G116", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0217", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0217", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0217" }, { "errorId": "ST0218", "site": "expedia", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/10-expedia/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/10-expedia/dist", "reviewGroup": "G116", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0218", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0218", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0218" }, { "errorId": "ST0221", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G119", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0221", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0221", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0221" }, { "errorId": "ST0222", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G120", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0222", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0222", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0222" }, { "errorId": "ST0223", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G121", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0223", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0223", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0223" }, { "errorId": "ST0224", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G122", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Native enclosing-label association and AX names Pick-up time and Return time identify both selects. The orphaned-label report has no corresponding naming failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Pick-up and return time selects are implicitly labelled; AX exposes Pick-up time and Return time. The reported orphaning is contradicted by DOM and AX." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The pickup and return time selects have enclosing labels, and AX reports Pick-up time and Return time. Their accessible names are present without explicit for attributes." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Native enclosing-label association and AX names Pick-up time and Return time identify both selects. The orphaned-label report has no corresponding naming failure. | B: Pick-up and return time selects are implicitly labelled; AX exposes Pick-up time and Return time. The reported orphaning is contradicted by DOM and AX. | C: The pickup and return time selects have enclosing labels, and AX reports Pick-up time and Return time. Their accessible names are present without explicit for attributes.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0224", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0224", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0224" }, { "errorId": "ST0225", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G122", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Native enclosing-label association and AX names Pick-up time and Return time identify both selects. The orphaned-label report has no corresponding naming failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Pick-up and return time selects are implicitly labelled; AX exposes Pick-up time and Return time. The reported orphaning is contradicted by DOM and AX." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The pickup and return time selects have enclosing labels, and AX reports Pick-up time and Return time. Their accessible names are present without explicit for attributes." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Native enclosing-label association and AX names Pick-up time and Return time identify both selects. The orphaned-label report has no corresponding naming failure. | B: Pick-up and return time selects are implicitly labelled; AX exposes Pick-up time and Return time. The reported orphaning is contradicted by DOM and AX. | C: The pickup and return time selects have enclosing labels, and AX reports Pick-up time and Return time. Their accessible names are present without explicit for attributes.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0225", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0225", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0225" }, { "errorId": "ST0226", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G123", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosed selects have AX names Renter age, Vehicle class and Passengers. Native association and meaningful names refute the orphaned-label mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Nested label/select association and AX names Renter age, Vehicle class, and Passengers provide the requested control meanings." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosing labels name the age, vehicle-class and passenger selects, with corresponding AX names confirmed. The orphaned-label alert does not reflect a naming failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The enclosed selects have AX names Renter age, Vehicle class and Passengers. Native association and meaningful names refute the orphaned-label mechanism. | B: Nested label/select association and AX names Renter age, Vehicle class, and Passengers provide the requested control meanings. | C: The enclosing labels name the age, vehicle-class and passenger selects, with corresponding AX names confirmed. The orphaned-label alert does not reflect a naming failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0226", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0226", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0226" }, { "errorId": "ST0227", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G123", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosed selects have AX names Renter age, Vehicle class and Passengers. Native association and meaningful names refute the orphaned-label mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Nested label/select association and AX names Renter age, Vehicle class, and Passengers provide the requested control meanings." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosing labels name the age, vehicle-class and passenger selects, with corresponding AX names confirmed. The orphaned-label alert does not reflect a naming failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The enclosed selects have AX names Renter age, Vehicle class and Passengers. Native association and meaningful names refute the orphaned-label mechanism. | B: Nested label/select association and AX names Renter age, Vehicle class, and Passengers provide the requested control meanings. | C: The enclosing labels name the age, vehicle-class and passenger selects, with corresponding AX names confirmed. The orphaned-label alert does not reflect a naming failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0227", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0227", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0227" }, { "errorId": "ST0228", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G123", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosed selects have AX names Renter age, Vehicle class and Passengers. Native association and meaningful names refute the orphaned-label mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Nested label/select association and AX names Renter age, Vehicle class, and Passengers provide the requested control meanings." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The enclosing labels name the age, vehicle-class and passenger selects, with corresponding AX names confirmed. The orphaned-label alert does not reflect a naming failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The enclosed selects have AX names Renter age, Vehicle class and Passengers. Native association and meaningful names refute the orphaned-label mechanism. | B: Nested label/select association and AX names Renter age, Vehicle class, and Passengers provide the requested control meanings. | C: The enclosing labels name the age, vehicle-class and passenger selects, with corresponding AX names confirmed. The orphaned-label alert does not reflect a naming failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0228", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0228", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0228" }, { "errorId": "ST0229", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G124", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The branded home link and Rent entry in the named primary navigation provide distinct banner/navigation entry points. Their common homepage URL alone does not make Rent an unnecessary duplicate action." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "A branded home link and the Rent entry in primary navigation provide established, differently situated navigation affordances. Matching root URLs do not establish a redundant same-content card action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The brand home link and Rent entry occupy different header roles: branding and the named primary navigation. Their shared home URL does not by itself make the navigation entry an unnecessary repeated card action." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The branded home link and Rent entry in the named primary navigation provide distinct banner/navigation entry points. Their common homepage URL alone does not make Rent an unnecessary duplicate action. | B: A branded home link and the Rent entry in primary navigation provide established, differently situated navigation affordances. Matching root URLs do not establish a redundant same-content card action. | C: The brand home link and Rent entry occupy different header roles: branding and the named primary navigation. Their shared home URL does not by itself make the navigation entry an unnecessary repeated card action.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0229", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0229", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0229" }, { "errorId": "ST0230", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G125", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0230", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0230", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0230" }, { "errorId": "ST0231", "site": "enterprise", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/11-enterprise/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/11-enterprise/dist", "reviewGroup": "G125", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0231", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0231", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0231" }, { "errorId": "ST0232", "site": "airbnb", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/12-airbnb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/12-airbnb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G126", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0232", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0232", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0232" }, { "errorId": "ST0236", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G130", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0236", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0236", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0236" }, { "errorId": "ST0237", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G131", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0237", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0237", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0237" }, { "errorId": "ST0238", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G132", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0238", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0238", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0238" }, { "errorId": "ST0239", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G133", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0239", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0239", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0239" }, { "errorId": "ST0240", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G134", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0240", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0240", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0240" }, { "errorId": "ST0241", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G134", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0240", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0240 (E039); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0241", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0241", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E039", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata spans use the same .event-card-meta span declaration and actual 10px with matching badge treatment. One local event-metadata font-size repair addresses all six instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata labels repeat the same .event-card-meta span treatment at an actual 10px with matching foreground/background. One event-metadata font-size change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata badges share .event-card-meta span and a computed 10px size. Changing that metadata-label size is one common component repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0241" }, { "errorId": "ST0242", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G134", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0240", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0240 (E039); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0242", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0242", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E039", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata spans use the same .event-card-meta span declaration and actual 10px with matching badge treatment. One local event-metadata font-size repair addresses all six instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata labels repeat the same .event-card-meta span treatment at an actual 10px with matching foreground/background. One event-metadata font-size change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata badges share .event-card-meta span and a computed 10px size. Changing that metadata-label size is one common component repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0242" }, { "errorId": "ST0243", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G134", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0240", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0240 (E039); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0243", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0243", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E039", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata spans use the same .event-card-meta span declaration and actual 10px with matching badge treatment. One local event-metadata font-size repair addresses all six instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata labels repeat the same .event-card-meta span treatment at an actual 10px with matching foreground/background. One event-metadata font-size change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata badges share .event-card-meta span and a computed 10px size. Changing that metadata-label size is one common component repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0243" }, { "errorId": "ST0244", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G134", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0240", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0240 (E039); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0244", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0244", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E039", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata spans use the same .event-card-meta span declaration and actual 10px with matching badge treatment. One local event-metadata font-size repair addresses all six instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata labels repeat the same .event-card-meta span treatment at an actual 10px with matching foreground/background. One event-metadata font-size change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata badges share .event-card-meta span and a computed 10px size. Changing that metadata-label size is one common component repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0244" }, { "errorId": "ST0245", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G134", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0240", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0240 (E039); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0245", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0245", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E039", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata spans use the same .event-card-meta span declaration and actual 10px with matching badge treatment. One local event-metadata font-size repair addresses all six instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata labels repeat the same .event-card-meta span treatment at an actual 10px with matching foreground/background. One event-metadata font-size change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The event metadata badges share .event-card-meta span and a computed 10px size. Changing that metadata-label size is one common component repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Bgq-XdH5.css\", \"selector\": \".event-card-meta span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(21, 21, 21)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0245" }, { "errorId": "ST0246", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G135", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0246", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0246", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0246" }, { "errorId": "ST0247", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G135", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0247", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0247", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0247" }, { "errorId": "ST0248", "site": "stubhub", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/13-stubhub/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/13-stubhub/dist", "reviewGroup": "G135", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0248", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0248", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0248" }, { "errorId": "ST0255", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G139", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0255", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0255", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0255" }, { "errorId": "ST0256", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G139", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0256", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0256", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0256" }, { "errorId": "ST0257", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G139", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0257", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0257", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0257" }, { "errorId": "ST0258", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G140", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0258", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0258", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0258" }, { "errorId": "ST0259", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G141", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The branded SoundCloud home link and Home within primary navigation serve recognizable site-brand and navigation contexts. Shared URL is insufficient to establish redundant interaction burden here." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The branded SoundCloud home link and explicit Home entry in primary navigation have useful separate navigation contexts. Same URL alone is insufficient for redundancy." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "SoundCloud home branding and Home in Primary navigation provide contextual home access in distinct header structures. The common URL is insufficient evidence of harmful redundant stopping." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The branded SoundCloud home link and Home within primary navigation serve recognizable site-brand and navigation contexts. Shared URL is insufficient to establish redundant interaction burden here. | B: The branded SoundCloud home link and explicit Home entry in primary navigation have useful separate navigation contexts. Same URL alone is insufficient for redundancy. | C: SoundCloud home branding and Home in Primary navigation provide contextual home access in distinct header structures. The common URL is insufficient evidence of harmful redundant stopping.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0259", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0259", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0259" }, { "errorId": "ST0260", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G142", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX shows adjacent MC and Maya Cove links to the same artist in one creator card. Inferred consequence: keyboard/link traversal encounters the same artist action twice, with initials adding no distinct action." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes MC and Maya Cove as successive links to the same creator inside one creator card. Inferred: two sequential stops perform the same creator-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes separate MC and Maya Cove links to the same creator consecutively within one creator card. Both open the same creator and add a repeated keyboard stop; the short initials also require interpreting a second name. Consequence inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AX shows adjacent MC and Maya Cove links to the same artist in one creator card. Inferred consequence: keyboard/link traversal encounters the same artist action twice, with initials adding no distinct action. | B: AX exposes MC and Maya Cove as successive links to the same creator inside one creator card. Inferred: two sequential stops perform the same creator-navigation action. | C: AX exposes separate MC and Maya Cove links to the same creator consecutively within one creator card. Both open the same creator and add a repeated keyboard stop; the short initials also require interpreting a second name. Consequence inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0260", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0260", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0260" }, { "errorId": "ST0261", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G143", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0261", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0261", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0261" }, { "errorId": "ST0262", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G144", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0262", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0262", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0262" }, { "errorId": "ST0263", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G144", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0262", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0262 (E041); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-line span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(105, 105, 105)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0263", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0263", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E041", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag pills share .tag-line span and actual 10px with matching foreground and background. Correcting this specific tag font-size once addresses all repeated tag instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag chips repeat the same .tag-line span component at an actual 10px with matching colors. One hashtag-chip font-size repair covers this repeated treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag chips share .tag-line span and the computed 10px font size. Repairing this one tag-chip size declaration addresses all listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-line span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(105, 105, 105)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0263" }, { "errorId": "ST0264", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G143", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0261", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0261 (E040); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kind\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0264", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0264", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E040", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Album and playlist kind labels share .card-kind and actual 10px with the same overlay styling. Their common small-text repair is one font-size change to that exact kind-label rule, independent of image backgrounds." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The ALBUM/PLAYLIST labels are repeated card-kind badges sharing .card-kind at an actual 10px with the same overlay treatment. One card-kind font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The Album/Playlist type labels share .card-kind and an actual 10px font size. One repair to that card-type label size covers the listed variants." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kind\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0264" }, { "errorId": "ST0265", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G144", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0262", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0262 (E041); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-line span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(105, 105, 105)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0265", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0265", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E041", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag pills share .tag-line span and actual 10px with matching foreground and background. Correcting this specific tag font-size once addresses all repeated tag instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag chips repeat the same .tag-line span component at an actual 10px with matching colors. One hashtag-chip font-size repair covers this repeated treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag chips share .tag-line span and the computed 10px font size. Repairing this one tag-chip size declaration addresses all listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-line span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(105, 105, 105)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0265" }, { "errorId": "ST0266", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G143", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0261", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0261 (E040); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kind\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0266", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0266", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E040", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Album and playlist kind labels share .card-kind and actual 10px with the same overlay styling. Their common small-text repair is one font-size change to that exact kind-label rule, independent of image backgrounds." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The ALBUM/PLAYLIST labels are repeated card-kind badges sharing .card-kind at an actual 10px with the same overlay treatment. One card-kind font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The Album/Playlist type labels share .card-kind and an actual 10px font size. One repair to that card-type label size covers the listed variants." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kind\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0266" }, { "errorId": "ST0267", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G144", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0262", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0262 (E041); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-line span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(105, 105, 105)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0267", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0267", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E041", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag pills share .tag-line span and actual 10px with matching foreground and background. Correcting this specific tag font-size once addresses all repeated tag instances." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag chips repeat the same .tag-line span component at an actual 10px with matching colors. One hashtag-chip font-size repair covers this repeated treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The hashtag chips share .tag-line span and the computed 10px font size. Repairing this one tag-chip size declaration addresses all listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-PGMzDXyd.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-line span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(105, 105, 105)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0267" }, { "errorId": "ST0268", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G145", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0268", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0268", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0268" }, { "errorId": "ST0269", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G146", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0269", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0269", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0269" }, { "errorId": "ST0270", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G147", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0270", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0270", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0270" }, { "errorId": "ST0271", "site": "soundcloud", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/14-soundcloud/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/14-soundcloud/dist", "reviewGroup": "G147", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0271", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0271", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0271" }, { "errorId": "ST0304", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G153", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0304", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0304", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0304" }, { "errorId": "ST0305", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G153", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0305", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0305", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0305" }, { "errorId": "ST0306", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G153", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0306", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0306", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0306" }, { "errorId": "ST0307", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G153", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0307", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0307", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0307" }, { "errorId": "ST0308", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G153", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0308", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0308", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0308" }, { "errorId": "ST0309", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G153", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0309", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0309", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0309" }, { "errorId": "ST0310", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G154", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0310", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0310", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0310" }, { "errorId": "ST0311", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0311", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0311", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0311" }, { "errorId": "ST0312", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0312", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0312", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0312" }, { "errorId": "ST0313", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0313", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0313", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0313" }, { "errorId": "ST0314", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0314", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0314", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0314" }, { "errorId": "ST0315", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0315", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0315", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0315" }, { "errorId": "ST0316", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0316", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0316", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0316" }, { "errorId": "ST0317", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0317", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0317", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0317" }, { "errorId": "ST0318", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0318", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0318", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0318" }, { "errorId": "ST0319", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0319", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0319", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0319" }, { "errorId": "ST0320", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0320", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0320", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0320" }, { "errorId": "ST0321", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0321", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0321", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0321" }, { "errorId": "ST0322", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0322", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0322", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0322" }, { "errorId": "ST0323", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0323", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0323", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0323" }, { "errorId": "ST0324", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0324", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0324", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0324" }, { "errorId": "ST0325", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0325", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0325", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0325" }, { "errorId": "ST0326", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0326", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0326", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0326" }, { "errorId": "ST0327", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0327", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0327", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0327" }, { "errorId": "ST0328", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0328", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0328", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0328" }, { "errorId": "ST0329", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0329", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0329", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0329" }, { "errorId": "ST0330", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0330", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0330", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0330" }, { "errorId": "ST0331", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0331", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0331", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0331" }, { "errorId": "ST0332", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0332", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0332", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0332" }, { "errorId": "ST0333", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G155", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0310", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0310 (E016); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0333", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0333", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E016", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE all members share .overline and identical actual color/size as section overlines. One local correction to this specific overline color treatment addresses the source relationship. Final contrast across the sections is not adjudicated, and axe reports remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/ESPN, the repeated section-overline captions share the active .overline foreground treatment. One local overline color repair covers the source mechanism; axe findings remain separate." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE overline candidates share the precise .overline color source and applied computed style. One overline-color repair covers this group within WAVE." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--subtle)\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0333" }, { "errorId": "ST0334", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "heading_skipped", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G156", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The h3 story heading follows the page h1 with no h2 organizing its story section in the saved AX sequence. Inferred consequence: screen-reader heading-level orientation presents a missing intermediate level; this is a structural inference, not an observed task failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The same story h3 follows the main h1 without an h2 grouping in the supplied AX sequence. Inferred: skipped structural level interferes with accurate heading-level orientation; no actual navigation trace is claimed." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX confirms the news-story h3 follows the main h1 without a containing h2 in the heading sequence. The skipped semantic hierarchy affects SR heading orientation; inferred. This WAVE report is evaluated separately from axe for duplicate purposes." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The h3 story heading follows the page h1 with no h2 organizing its story section in the saved AX sequence. Inferred consequence: screen-reader heading-level orientation presents a missing intermediate level; this is a structural inference, not an observed task failure. | B: The same story h3 follows the main h1 without an h2 grouping in the supplied AX sequence. Inferred: skipped structural level interferes with accurate heading-level orientation; no actual navigation trace is claimed. | C: AX confirms the news-story h3 follows the main h1 without a containing h2 in the heading sequence. The skipped semantic hierarchy affects SR heading orientation; inferred. This WAVE report is evaluated separately from axe for duplicate purposes.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0334", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0334", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0334" }, { "errorId": "ST0335", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G157", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0335", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0335", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0335" }, { "errorId": "ST0336", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G158", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0336", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0336", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0336" }, { "errorId": "ST0337", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G158", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0337", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0337", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0337" }, { "errorId": "ST0338", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G158", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0338", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0338", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0338" }, { "errorId": "ST0339", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G158", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0339", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0339", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0339" }, { "errorId": "ST0340", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G159", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0340", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0340", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0340" }, { "errorId": "ST0341", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G160", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0341", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0341", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0341" }, { "errorId": "ST0342", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G161", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0342", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0342", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0342" }, { "errorId": "ST0343", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G161", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0343", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0343", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0343" }, { "errorId": "ST0344", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0344", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0344", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0344" }, { "errorId": "ST0345", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0345", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0345", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0345" }, { "errorId": "ST0346", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0346", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0346", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0346" }, { "errorId": "ST0347", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0347", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0347", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0347" }, { "errorId": "ST0348", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0348", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0348", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0348" }, { "errorId": "ST0349", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0349", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0349", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0349" }, { "errorId": "ST0350", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0350", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0350", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0350" }, { "errorId": "ST0351", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0351", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0351", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0351" }, { "errorId": "ST0352", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0352", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0352", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0352" }, { "errorId": "ST0353", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0353", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0353", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0353" }, { "errorId": "ST0354", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0354", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0354", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0354" }, { "errorId": "ST0355", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0355", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0355", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0355" }, { "errorId": "ST0356", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0356", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0356", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0356" }, { "errorId": "ST0357", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0357", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0357", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0357" }, { "errorId": "ST0358", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0358", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0358", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0358" }, { "errorId": "ST0359", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0359", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0359", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0359" }, { "errorId": "ST0360", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0360", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0360", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0360" }, { "errorId": "ST0361", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0361", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0361", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0361" }, { "errorId": "ST0362", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0362", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0362", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0362" }, { "errorId": "ST0363", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0363", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0363", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0363" }, { "errorId": "ST0364", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0364", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0364", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0364" }, { "errorId": "ST0365", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0365", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0365", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0365" }, { "errorId": "ST0366", "site": "espn", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/15-espn/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/15-espn/dist", "reviewGroup": "G162", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0340", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0340 (E042); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0366", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0366", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E042", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All section overlines share .overline and actual 10.24px from 0.64rem. One local overline font-size change directly addresses the reported small-text property across sections; section background differences are not relevant to this mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates repeat section-overline captions with the same active .overline size of 10.24px. A single local overline font-size repair addresses this typography role across sections." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The section overlines share .overline and the actual 10.24px size. A single overline font-size repair covers these repeated labels; it is distinct from repairing their foreground color." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.64rem\", \"file\": \"index-DJhTGc6P.css\", \"selector\": \".overline\"}]；目标共享 rgb(140, 145, 152)/10.24px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0366" }, { "errorId": "ST0367", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G163", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0367", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0367", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0367" }, { "errorId": "ST0368", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G163", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0368", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0368", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0368" }, { "errorId": "ST0369", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G163", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0369", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0369", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0369" }, { "errorId": "ST0370", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G163", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0370", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0370", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0370" }, { "errorId": "ST0371", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G163", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0371", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0371", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0371" }, { "errorId": "ST0372", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G164", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The supplied hero AX sequence has an unlinked title and synopsis, an independent watchlist action, then More info. This is a distinct details-navigation entry rather than a demonstrated adjacent repeated title link." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The supplied complete hero exposes one More info action after the film description and watchlist button. It does not demonstrate another equivalent local link stop; equal destinations elsewhere are not sufficient." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "More info is a standalone title-information action in the hero following the synopsis and watchlist control. The supplied local AX structure does not show a repeated title-opening link there; a matching URL in another page section is not sufficient to call this hero action redundant." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The supplied hero AX sequence has an unlinked title and synopsis, an independent watchlist action, then More info. This is a distinct details-navigation entry rather than a demonstrated adjacent repeated title link. | B: The supplied complete hero exposes one More info action after the film description and watchlist button. It does not demonstrate another equivalent local link stop; equal destinations elsewhere are not sufficient. | C: More info is a standalone title-information action in the hero following the synopsis and watchlist control. The supplied local AX structure does not show a repeated title-opening link there; a matching URL in another page section is not sufficient to call this hero action redundant.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0372", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0372", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0372" }, { "errorId": "ST0373", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0373", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0373", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0373" }, { "errorId": "ST0374", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0374", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0374", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0374" }, { "errorId": "ST0375", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0375", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0375", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0375" }, { "errorId": "ST0376", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0376", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0376", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0376" }, { "errorId": "ST0377", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0377", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0377", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0377" }, { "errorId": "ST0378", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0378", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0378", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0378" }, { "errorId": "ST0379", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0379", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0379", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0379" }, { "errorId": "ST0380", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0380", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0380", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0380" }, { "errorId": "ST0381", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0381", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0381", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0381" }, { "errorId": "ST0382", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0382", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0382", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0382" }, { "errorId": "ST0383", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0383", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0383", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0383" }, { "errorId": "ST0384", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0384", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0384", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0384" }, { "errorId": "ST0385", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0385", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0385", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0385" }, { "errorId": "ST0386", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0386", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0386", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0386" }, { "errorId": "ST0387", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0387", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0387", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0387" }, { "errorId": "ST0388", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G165", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0373", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0373 (P07; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each title card exposes a linked named poster plus a title link to the same item, with independent watchlist controls retained. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats the title-details destination in every card; AX and the shared constructor establish the mechanism. | B: Each title card separately exposes a poster link and full title link to the same title. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats title navigation; watchlist/trailer actions remain distinct. | C: Each card's AX exposes a named poster link and a separate title link for the same title, even with the watchlist control between them. The product-opening action is repeated within one card, adding keyboard traversal and SR naming; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0388", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0388", "duplicateProposal": "P07", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen instances use wi with the same linked-poster/title structure. One modification to consolidate those links while preserving the separate watchlist control repairs this repeated navigation defect in each instance; supported by source and AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All sixteen candidates use wi, which independently links the poster and title to the same item. The same constructor repair covers them without changing independent watchlist/trailer controls." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "All 16 cards use wi, whose poster and title links duplicate the same title-opening action. Repairing that constructor while preserving its independent watchlist button addresses the common source defect across ordinary and ranked instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0388" }, { "errorId": "ST0389", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G166", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy identify distinct footer purposes. Their shared /about URL does not itself establish redundant stops, and no destination behavior is supplied to adjudicate a different misrouting defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use, and Privacy Policy express distinct navigation purposes. Their shared placeholder-like URL does not make the named entries redundant; destination correctness is a different unverified mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy express distinct footer destinations or purposes. Sharing /about does not establish semantically redundant stops. The evidence does not establish the destination-page behavior, so this vote does not invent a separate link-purpose failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy identify distinct footer purposes. Their shared /about URL does not itself establish redundant stops, and no destination behavior is supplied to adjudicate a different misrouting defect. | B: Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use, and Privacy Policy express distinct navigation purposes. Their shared placeholder-like URL does not make the named entries redundant; destination correctness is a different unverified mechanism. | C: Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy express distinct footer destinations or purposes. Sharing /about does not establish semantically redundant stops. The evidence does not establish the destination-page behavior, so this vote does not invent a separate link-purpose failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0389", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0389", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0389" }, { "errorId": "ST0390", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G166", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy identify distinct footer purposes. Their shared /about URL does not itself establish redundant stops, and no destination behavior is supplied to adjudicate a different misrouting defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use, and Privacy Policy express distinct navigation purposes. Their shared placeholder-like URL does not make the named entries redundant; destination correctness is a different unverified mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy express distinct footer destinations or purposes. Sharing /about does not establish semantically redundant stops. The evidence does not establish the destination-page behavior, so this vote does not invent a separate link-purpose failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy identify distinct footer purposes. Their shared /about URL does not itself establish redundant stops, and no destination behavior is supplied to adjudicate a different misrouting defect. | B: Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use, and Privacy Policy express distinct navigation purposes. Their shared placeholder-like URL does not make the named entries redundant; destination correctness is a different unverified mechanism. | C: Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy express distinct footer destinations or purposes. Sharing /about does not establish semantically redundant stops. The evidence does not establish the destination-page behavior, so this vote does not invent a separate link-purpose failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0390", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0390", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0390" }, { "errorId": "ST0391", "site": "imdb", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/16-imdb/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/16-imdb/dist", "reviewGroup": "G166", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy identify distinct footer purposes. Their shared /about URL does not itself establish redundant stops, and no destination behavior is supplied to adjudicate a different misrouting defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use, and Privacy Policy express distinct navigation purposes. Their shared placeholder-like URL does not make the named entries redundant; destination correctness is a different unverified mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy express distinct footer destinations or purposes. Sharing /about does not establish semantically redundant stops. The evidence does not establish the destination-page behavior, so this vote does not invent a separate link-purpose failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy identify distinct footer purposes. Their shared /about URL does not itself establish redundant stops, and no destination behavior is supplied to adjudicate a different misrouting defect. | B: Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use, and Privacy Policy express distinct navigation purposes. Their shared placeholder-like URL does not make the named entries redundant; destination correctness is a different unverified mechanism. | C: Help, IMDbPro, Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy express distinct footer destinations or purposes. Sharing /about does not establish semantically redundant stops. The evidence does not establish the destination-page behavior, so this vote does not invent a separate link-purpose failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0391", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0391", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0391" }, { "errorId": "ST0394", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G169", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0394", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0394", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0394" }, { "errorId": "ST0395", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G170", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Steam's branded home link and STORE inside named main navigation provide distinct global navigation contexts. A common home URL does not alone prove a redundant card-like stop." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Steam's branded home link and STORE inside main navigation serve separate orientation/navigation contexts. The repeated root destination alone does not establish useless sequential duplication." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Steam Store home branding and STORE in Main navigation have distinct header orientation roles. The same URL does not alone establish redundant local content actions." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Steam's branded home link and STORE inside named main navigation provide distinct global navigation contexts. A common home URL does not alone prove a redundant card-like stop. | B: Steam's branded home link and STORE inside main navigation serve separate orientation/navigation contexts. The repeated root destination alone does not establish useless sequential duplication. | C: Steam Store home branding and STORE in Main navigation have distinct header orientation roles. The same URL does not alone establish redundant local content actions.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0395", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0395", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0395" }, { "errorId": "ST0396", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G171", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The same featured game's artwork link and View details link both appear within one hero and target its details. Inferred consequence: sequential link navigation repeats that game-details action; the AX explicitly exposes both endpoints despite intervening descriptive content." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The same featured-game hero exposes a linked artwork and a later View details link to that game. Inferred: separate links repeat the same featured-game navigation action; the supplied AX establishes both exposures." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The hero AX exposes a featured-artwork link and the later View details link to the same featured game within the same hero. These provide two game-opening keyboard stops around descriptive content; the repeated local action is inferred from AX, without claiming an observed trajectory." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The same featured game's artwork link and View details link both appear within one hero and target its details. Inferred consequence: sequential link navigation repeats that game-details action; the AX explicitly exposes both endpoints despite intervening descriptive content. | B: The same featured-game hero exposes a linked artwork and a later View details link to that game. Inferred: separate links repeat the same featured-game navigation action; the supplied AX establishes both exposures. | C: The hero AX exposes a featured-artwork link and the later View details link to the same featured game within the same hero. These provide two game-opening keyboard stops around descriptive content; the repeated local action is inferred from AX, without claiming an observed trajectory.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0396", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0396", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0396" }, { "errorId": "ST0397", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G172", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX and source show a game-cover link followed by the same game's heading link in each offer card. Inferred consequence: consecutive equivalent game-details stops during keyboard/screen-reader link navigation." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each offer card exposes both the game-cover link and title link to the same game. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same card destination." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each offer card exposes separate game-cover and game-title links to the same game. AX supports a repeated local opening action and extra keyboard/SR traversal; consequence inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AX and source show a game-cover link followed by the same game's heading link in each offer card. Inferred consequence: consecutive equivalent game-details stops during keyboard/screen-reader link navigation. | B: Each offer card exposes both the game-cover link and title link to the same game. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same card destination. | C: Each offer card exposes separate game-cover and game-title links to the same game. AX supports a repeated local opening action and extra keyboard/SR traversal; consequence inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0397", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0397", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0397" }, { "errorId": "ST0398", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G172", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0397", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX and source show a game-cover link followed by the same game's heading link in each offer card. Inferred consequence: consecutive equivalent game-details stops during keyboard/screen-reader link navigation." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each offer card exposes both the game-cover link and title link to the same game. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same card destination." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each offer card exposes separate game-cover and game-title links to the same game. AX supports a repeated local opening action and extra keyboard/SR traversal; consequence inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0397 (P08; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX and source show a game-cover link followed by the same game's heading link in each offer card. Inferred consequence: consecutive equivalent game-details stops during keyboard/screen-reader link navigation. | B: Each offer card exposes both the game-cover link and title link to the same game. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same card destination. | C: Each offer card exposes separate game-cover and game-title links to the same game. AX supports a repeated local opening action and extra keyboard/SR traversal; consequence inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0398", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0398", "duplicateProposal": "P08", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Gx emits both cover and title links for each listed game. Consolidating this specific pair in the shared constructor repairs all three repeated game-navigation stops." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All three game cards use Gx with the same cover/title duplicate links. One shared constructor change resolves the same defect for the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared Gx function creates separate cover and title links for each game card. One repair of that function's game-opening structure resolves the repeated-stop mechanism in all listed instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0398" }, { "errorId": "ST0399", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G172", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0397", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX and source show a game-cover link followed by the same game's heading link in each offer card. Inferred consequence: consecutive equivalent game-details stops during keyboard/screen-reader link navigation." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each offer card exposes both the game-cover link and title link to the same game. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same card destination." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each offer card exposes separate game-cover and game-title links to the same game. AX supports a repeated local opening action and extra keyboard/SR traversal; consequence inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0397 (P08; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: AX and source show a game-cover link followed by the same game's heading link in each offer card. Inferred consequence: consecutive equivalent game-details stops during keyboard/screen-reader link navigation. | B: Each offer card exposes both the game-cover link and title link to the same game. Inferred: sequential navigation repeats the same card destination. | C: Each offer card exposes separate game-cover and game-title links to the same game. AX supports a repeated local opening action and extra keyboard/SR traversal; consequence inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0399", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0399", "duplicateProposal": "P08", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Gx emits both cover and title links for each listed game. Consolidating this specific pair in the shared constructor repairs all three repeated game-navigation stops." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All three game cards use Gx with the same cover/title duplicate links. One shared constructor change resolves the same defect for the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared Gx function creates separate cover and title links for each game card. One repair of that function's game-opening structure resolves the repeated-stop mechanism in all listed instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0399" }, { "errorId": "ST0400", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G173", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The chart links each contain a distinct game's name, rank and player count. A common chart destination does not make these distinct row information/actions redundant, and destination correctness is not established by this candidate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each link is a distinct named game row with its own rank/player information. Reusing the chart URL does not prove repeated equivalent stops; no destination-page defect is substituted for the reported redundancy." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The chart rows name distinct games and include distinct player counts. They are not duplicate representations of one item merely because several URLs point to the same chart. No destination behavior evidence establishes another failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The chart links each contain a distinct game's name, rank and player count. A common chart destination does not make these distinct row information/actions redundant, and destination correctness is not established by this candidate. | B: Each link is a distinct named game row with its own rank/player information. Reusing the chart URL does not prove repeated equivalent stops; no destination-page defect is substituted for the reported redundancy. | C: The chart rows name distinct games and include distinct player counts. They are not duplicate representations of one item merely because several URLs point to the same chart. No destination behavior evidence establishes another failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0400", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0400", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0400" }, { "errorId": "ST0401", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G173", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The chart links each contain a distinct game's name, rank and player count. A common chart destination does not make these distinct row information/actions redundant, and destination correctness is not established by this candidate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each link is a distinct named game row with its own rank/player information. Reusing the chart URL does not prove repeated equivalent stops; no destination-page defect is substituted for the reported redundancy." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The chart rows name distinct games and include distinct player counts. They are not duplicate representations of one item merely because several URLs point to the same chart. No destination behavior evidence establishes another failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The chart links each contain a distinct game's name, rank and player count. A common chart destination does not make these distinct row information/actions redundant, and destination correctness is not established by this candidate. | B: Each link is a distinct named game row with its own rank/player information. Reusing the chart URL does not prove repeated equivalent stops; no destination-page defect is substituted for the reported redundancy. | C: The chart rows name distinct games and include distinct player counts. They are not duplicate representations of one item merely because several URLs point to the same chart. No destination behavior evidence establishes another failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0401", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0401", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0401" }, { "errorId": "ST0402", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G173", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The chart links each contain a distinct game's name, rank and player count. A common chart destination does not make these distinct row information/actions redundant, and destination correctness is not established by this candidate." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each link is a distinct named game row with its own rank/player information. Reusing the chart URL does not prove repeated equivalent stops; no destination-page defect is substituted for the reported redundancy." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The chart rows name distinct games and include distinct player counts. They are not duplicate representations of one item merely because several URLs point to the same chart. No destination behavior evidence establishes another failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The chart links each contain a distinct game's name, rank and player count. A common chart destination does not make these distinct row information/actions redundant, and destination correctness is not established by this candidate. | B: Each link is a distinct named game row with its own rank/player information. Reusing the chart URL does not prove repeated equivalent stops; no destination-page defect is substituted for the reported redundancy. | C: The chart rows name distinct games and include distinct player counts. They are not duplicate representations of one item merely because several URLs point to the same chart. No destination behavior evidence establishes another failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0402", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0402", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0402" }, { "errorId": "ST0403", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G174", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure. | B: Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation. | C: Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0403", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0403", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0403" }, { "errorId": "ST0404", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G174", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure. | B: Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation. | C: Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0404", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0404", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0404" }, { "errorId": "ST0405", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G174", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure. | B: Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation. | C: Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0405", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0405", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0405" }, { "errorId": "ST0406", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G174", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each upcoming-game row exposes different game, date and count information in its name. Repeated /upcoming alone does not prove redundant stops for the same content or an observed destination failure. | B: Distinct game/date/count rows provide distinct information and names. Shared upcoming URL alone does not establish redundant sequential navigation. | C: Each upcoming-game row carries a different game name, date and count. Common /upcoming URLs do not make these distinct informational entries redundant keyboard/SR stops; destination correctness is not adjudicated from URL identity.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0406", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0406", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0406" }, { "errorId": "ST0407", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0407", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0407", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0407" }, { "errorId": "ST0408", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0408", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0408", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0408" }, { "errorId": "ST0409", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0409", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0409", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0409" }, { "errorId": "ST0410", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0410", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0410", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0410" }, { "errorId": "ST0411", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0411", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0411", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0411" }, { "errorId": "ST0412", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0412", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0412", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0412" }, { "errorId": "ST0413", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0413", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0413", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0413" }, { "errorId": "ST0414", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0414", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0414", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0414" }, { "errorId": "ST0415", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G175", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0407", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0407 (E043); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0415", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0415", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E043", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The game genre tags share .tag-row span and actual 10px with matching tag styling. A single change to the local tag font-size declaration addresses all nine repeated genre-tag reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-tag chips share the same .tag-row span declaration and actual 10px size with matching foreground/background treatment. One tag-chip font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The game-genre tags share .tag-row span and a computed 10px font size. One tag-label size repair covers these repeated game-card fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-CPVGKwKH.css\", \"selector\": \".tag-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(103, 184, 232)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0415" }, { "errorId": "ST0416", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G176", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0416", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0416", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0416" }, { "errorId": "ST0417", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G176", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0417", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0417", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0417" }, { "errorId": "ST0418", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G176", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0418", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0418", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0418" }, { "errorId": "ST0419", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G176", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0419", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0419", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0419" }, { "errorId": "ST0420", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G176", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0420", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0420", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0420" }, { "errorId": "ST0421", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G177", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0421", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0421", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0421" }, { "errorId": "ST0422", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G177", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0422", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0422", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0422" }, { "errorId": "ST0423", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G177", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0423", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0423", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0423" }, { "errorId": "ST0424", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G177", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0424", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0424", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0424" }, { "errorId": "ST0425", "site": "store.steampowered", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/17-store.steampowered/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/17-store.steampowered/dist", "reviewGroup": "G178", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0425", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0425", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0425" }, { "errorId": "ST0428", "site": "redfin", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/18-redfin/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/18-redfin/dist", "reviewGroup": "G180", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0428", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0428", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0428" }, { "errorId": "ST0429", "site": "redfin", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/18-redfin/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/18-redfin/dist", "reviewGroup": "G181", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0429", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0429", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0429" }, { "errorId": "ST0430", "site": "redfin", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/18-redfin/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/18-redfin/dist", "reviewGroup": "G182", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0430", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0430", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0430" }, { "errorId": "ST0431", "site": "redfin", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/18-redfin/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/18-redfin/dist", "reviewGroup": "G183", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0431", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0431", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0431" }, { "errorId": "ST0432", "site": "redfin", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/18-redfin/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/18-redfin/dist", "reviewGroup": "G183", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0432", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0432", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0432" }, { "errorId": "ST0433", "site": "indeed", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/19-indeed/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/19-indeed/dist", "reviewGroup": "G184", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "See all recent searches is the aggregate entry beneath Pick up where you left off; nearby buttons reopen individual searches. The supplied structure provides distinct actions and no equivalent adjacent aggregate link." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "See all recent searches is the sole supplied all-searches entry in its continuation section; nearby recent-search controls are individual actions. No equivalent local redundant link is demonstrated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "See all recent searches is the action for the Pick up where you left off section, following separate recent-search controls. The supplied local AX identifies a contextual overview action, not two adjacent equivalent links." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: See all recent searches is the aggregate entry beneath Pick up where you left off; nearby buttons reopen individual searches. The supplied structure provides distinct actions and no equivalent adjacent aggregate link. | B: See all recent searches is the sole supplied all-searches entry in its continuation section; nearby recent-search controls are individual actions. No equivalent local redundant link is demonstrated. | C: See all recent searches is the action for the Pick up where you left off section, following separate recent-search controls. The supplied local AX identifies a contextual overview action, not two adjacent equivalent links.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0433", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0433", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0433" }, { "errorId": "ST0454", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G191", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0454", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0454", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0454" }, { "errorId": "ST0455", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G192", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0455", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0455", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0455" }, { "errorId": "ST0456", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G193", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0456", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0456", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0456" }, { "errorId": "ST0457", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G194", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0457", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0457", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0457" }, { "errorId": "ST0458", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G195", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0458", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0458", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0458" }, { "errorId": "ST0459", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G196", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0459", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0459", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0459" }, { "errorId": "ST0460", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0460", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0460", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0460" }, { "errorId": "ST0461", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0461", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0461", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0461" }, { "errorId": "ST0462", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0462", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0462", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0462" }, { "errorId": "ST0463", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0463", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0463", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0463" }, { "errorId": "ST0464", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0464", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0464", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0464" }, { "errorId": "ST0465", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0465", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0465", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0465" }, { "errorId": "ST0466", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0466", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0466", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0466" }, { "errorId": "ST0467", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0467", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0467", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0467" }, { "errorId": "ST0468", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0468", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0468", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0468" }, { "errorId": "ST0469", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0469", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0469", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0469" }, { "errorId": "ST0470", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G196", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0470", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0470", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0470" }, { "errorId": "ST0471", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0471", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0471", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0471" }, { "errorId": "ST0472", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G197", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0472", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0472", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0472" }, { "errorId": "ST0473", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G198", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0473", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0473", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0473" }, { "errorId": "ST0474", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G199", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0474", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0474", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0474" }, { "errorId": "ST0475", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G198", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0473", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0473 (E019); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(125, 142, 150)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-rank\"}]；目标共享 rgb(125, 142, 150)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0475", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0475", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E019", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The community rank numbers all use .trend-rank with actual rgb(125,142,150) at 12px. A single local rank-color correction addresses the same rendered rank-field treatment in each row." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The candidates are repeated trend-rank numbers using the same .trend-rank declaration and matching actual foreground/size. One rank-label foreground repair is the concrete common change." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The ranking numbers use the same .trend-rank foreground declaration and computed size/color. Changing that rank-number text color is one concrete common repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(125, 142, 150)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-rank\"}]；目标共享 rgb(125, 142, 150)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0475" }, { "errorId": "ST0476", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G200", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0476", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0476", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0476" }, { "errorId": "ST0477", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G199", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0474", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0474 (E018); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(113, 131, 140)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-community small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(113, 131, 140)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0477", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0477", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E018", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE viewing-count candidates share .trend-community small and identical computed color/size. One correction to that repeated community-count text treatment addresses this group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE candidates repeat the viewing-count field of trend-community entries and share its active local foreground declaration. One component-field color change covers these instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE viewing-count captions share the .trend-community small declaration and matching computed foreground. They are repeated instances of the same caption-color source repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(113, 131, 140)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-community small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(113, 131, 140)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0477" }, { "errorId": "ST0478", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G198", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0473", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0473 (E019); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(125, 142, 150)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-rank\"}]；目标共享 rgb(125, 142, 150)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0478", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0478", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E019", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The community rank numbers all use .trend-rank with actual rgb(125,142,150) at 12px. A single local rank-color correction addresses the same rendered rank-field treatment in each row." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The candidates are repeated trend-rank numbers using the same .trend-rank declaration and matching actual foreground/size. One rank-label foreground repair is the concrete common change." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The ranking numbers use the same .trend-rank foreground declaration and computed size/color. Changing that rank-number text color is one concrete common repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(125, 142, 150)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-rank\"}]；目标共享 rgb(125, 142, 150)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0478" }, { "errorId": "ST0479", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G200", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0479", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0479", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0479" }, { "errorId": "ST0480", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G199", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0474", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0474 (E018); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(113, 131, 140)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-community small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(113, 131, 140)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0480", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0480", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E018", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE viewing-count candidates share .trend-community small and identical computed color/size. One correction to that repeated community-count text treatment addresses this group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE candidates repeat the viewing-count field of trend-community entries and share its active local foreground declaration. One component-field color change covers these instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE viewing-count captions share the .trend-community small declaration and matching computed foreground. They are repeated instances of the same caption-color source repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(113, 131, 140)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-community small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(113, 131, 140)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0480" }, { "errorId": "ST0481", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G198", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0473", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0473 (E019); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(125, 142, 150)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-rank\"}]；目标共享 rgb(125, 142, 150)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0481", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0481", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E019", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The community rank numbers all use .trend-rank with actual rgb(125,142,150) at 12px. A single local rank-color correction addresses the same rendered rank-field treatment in each row." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The candidates are repeated trend-rank numbers using the same .trend-rank declaration and matching actual foreground/size. One rank-label foreground repair is the concrete common change." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The ranking numbers use the same .trend-rank foreground declaration and computed size/color. Changing that rank-number text color is one concrete common repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(125, 142, 150)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-rank\"}]；目标共享 rgb(125, 142, 150)/12px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0481" }, { "errorId": "ST0482", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G200", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0482", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0482", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0482" }, { "errorId": "ST0483", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G199", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0474", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0474 (E018); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(113, 131, 140)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-community small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(113, 131, 140)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0483", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0483", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E018", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE viewing-count candidates share .trend-community small and identical computed color/size. One correction to that repeated community-count text treatment addresses this group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE candidates repeat the viewing-count field of trend-community entries and share its active local foreground declaration. One component-field color change covers these instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE viewing-count captions share the .trend-community small declaration and matching computed foreground. They are repeated instances of the same caption-color source repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(113, 131, 140)\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".trend-community small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(113, 131, 140)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0483" }, { "errorId": "ST0484", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "label_orphaned", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G201", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select has aria-label Popular location and AX confirms that name. The enclosing label has no text, but the control is adequately named and no orphaned-label interaction failure follows." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The select is nested in a label and explicitly named Popular location in both DOM and AX. The label wrapper does not cause an unnamed location selector." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The location select has aria-label Popular location and AX confirms that name. The enclosing label's lack of explicit association text does not leave the control unnamed." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The select has aria-label Popular location and AX confirms that name. The enclosing label has no text, but the control is adequately named and no orphaned-label interaction failure follows. | B: The select is nested in a label and explicitly named Popular location in both DOM and AX. The label wrapper does not cause an unnamed location selector. | C: The location select has aria-label Popular location and AX confirms that name. The enclosing label's lack of explicit association text does not leave the control unnamed.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0484", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0484", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0484" }, { "errorId": "ST0485", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G202", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0485", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0485", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0485" }, { "errorId": "ST0486", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G203", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0486", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0486", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0486" }, { "errorId": "ST0487", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G203", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0486", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0486 (E044); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0487", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0487", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E044", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge variants use the same combined .flair, .privacy-badge font-size rule and actual 10px, with matching colors in these instances. One change to that local badge-size declaration addresses all six small-text reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge labels share one explicit local .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10px, and the supplied instances have matching displayed treatment. One badge-label size change covers this repeated mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The labels use the explicit shared .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, with the same actual 10px size. One change to this common badge-size declaration addresses the text-size mechanism for the listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0487" }, { "errorId": "ST0488", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G203", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0486", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0486 (E044); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0488", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0488", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E044", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge variants use the same combined .flair, .privacy-badge font-size rule and actual 10px, with matching colors in these instances. One change to that local badge-size declaration addresses all six small-text reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge labels share one explicit local .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10px, and the supplied instances have matching displayed treatment. One badge-label size change covers this repeated mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The labels use the explicit shared .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, with the same actual 10px size. One change to this common badge-size declaration addresses the text-size mechanism for the listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0488" }, { "errorId": "ST0489", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G203", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0486", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0486 (E044); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0489", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0489", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E044", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge variants use the same combined .flair, .privacy-badge font-size rule and actual 10px, with matching colors in these instances. One change to that local badge-size declaration addresses all six small-text reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge labels share one explicit local .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10px, and the supplied instances have matching displayed treatment. One badge-label size change covers this repeated mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The labels use the explicit shared .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, with the same actual 10px size. One change to this common badge-size declaration addresses the text-size mechanism for the listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0489" }, { "errorId": "ST0490", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G203", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0486", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0486 (E044); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0490", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0490", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E044", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge variants use the same combined .flair, .privacy-badge font-size rule and actual 10px, with matching colors in these instances. One change to that local badge-size declaration addresses all six small-text reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge labels share one explicit local .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10px, and the supplied instances have matching displayed treatment. One badge-label size change covers this repeated mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The labels use the explicit shared .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, with the same actual 10px size. One change to this common badge-size declaration addresses the text-size mechanism for the listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0490" }, { "errorId": "ST0491", "site": "reddit", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/20-reddit/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/20-reddit/dist", "reviewGroup": "G203", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0486", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0486 (E044); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0491", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0491", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E044", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge variants use the same combined .flair, .privacy-badge font-size rule and actual 10px, with matching colors in these instances. One change to that local badge-size declaration addresses all six small-text reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The flair/badge labels share one explicit local .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, confirmed at 10px, and the supplied instances have matching displayed treatment. One badge-label size change covers this repeated mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The labels use the explicit shared .flair, .privacy-badge font-size declaration, with the same actual 10px size. One change to this common badge-size declaration addresses the text-size mechanism for the listed instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-BKbJOdE2.css\", \"selector\": \".flair, .privacy-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(136, 64, 31)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0491" }, { "errorId": "ST0584", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G227", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0584", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0584", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0584" }, { "errorId": "ST0585", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G227", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0585", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0585", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0585" }, { "errorId": "ST0586", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0586", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0586", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0586" }, { "errorId": "ST0587", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0587", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0587", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0587" }, { "errorId": "ST0588", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0588", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0588", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0588" }, { "errorId": "ST0589", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0589", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0589", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0589" }, { "errorId": "ST0590", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0590", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0590", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0590" }, { "errorId": "ST0591", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0591", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0591", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0591" }, { "errorId": "ST0592", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0592", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0592", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0592" }, { "errorId": "ST0593", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G228", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0586", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0586 (E021); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0593", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0593", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E021", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-course-price candidates share .price del and identical actual color/size. A local correction of that price treatment is one repair, kept separate from axe reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Udemy, repeated original course prices share the active .price del foreground treatment. One local original-price color change covers the listed instances." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE original-price findings share .price del and the same computed foreground. A single repair to that course-price subcomponent covers the group independently of axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(139, 133, 143)\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".price del\"}]；目标共享 rgb(139, 133, 143)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0593" }, { "errorId": "ST0594", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G229", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX exposes Cart with 0 courses twice consecutively across header/navigation boundaries with the same /cart action. Inferred consequence: redundant cart stops in sequential navigation; this is not merely a hidden DOM copy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX confirms two adjacent exposed Cart with 0 courses links to /cart in the header/navigation. Inferred: two sequential stops announce and perform the same cart action; this is not merely a hidden DOM copy." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "AX actually exposes two nearby Cart with 0 courses links to /cart in the header, including one immediately after navigation. These duplicate the same cart action/name and add a keyboard stop and repeated SR announcement; inferred from AX, not merely hidden DOM copies." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: AX exposes Cart with 0 courses twice consecutively across header/navigation boundaries with the same /cart action. Inferred consequence: redundant cart stops in sequential navigation; this is not merely a hidden DOM copy. | B: AX confirms two adjacent exposed Cart with 0 courses links to /cart in the header/navigation. Inferred: two sequential stops announce and perform the same cart action; this is not merely a hidden DOM copy. | C: AX actually exposes two nearby Cart with 0 courses links to /cart in the header, including one immediately after navigation. These duplicate the same cart action/name and add a keyboard stop and repeated SR announcement; inferred from AX, not merely hidden DOM copies.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0594", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0594", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0594" }, { "errorId": "ST0595", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0595", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0595", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0595" }, { "errorId": "ST0596", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0596", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0596", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0596" }, { "errorId": "ST0597", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0597", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0597", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0597" }, { "errorId": "ST0598", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0598", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0598", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0598" }, { "errorId": "ST0599", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0599", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0599", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0599" }, { "errorId": "ST0600", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0600", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0600", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0600" }, { "errorId": "ST0601", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0601", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0601", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0601" }, { "errorId": "ST0602", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G230", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": "ST0595", "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Duplicate of ST0595 (P09; Shared card constructor creates separate cover and title links; one constructor consolidation fixes all instances. Base majority: A: Each course card exposes a View-course cover link followed by a same-course heading link. Inferred consequence: duplicate course-details stops in keyboard/link navigation, supported by AX and the shared constructor. | B: Each course card exposes both View course and the course-title link to the same course. Inferred: repeated sequential links perform the same course-navigation action. | C: Each course card exposes separate View-course and course-title links to the identical course, before the wishlist and course information. AX supports repeated course-opening keyboard/SR stops; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0602", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0602", "duplicateProposal": "P09", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The shared yu constructor emits a View-course cover link and course-heading link for all eight courses. A single link-structure repair addresses precisely the repeated course destination while preserving wishlist controls." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All eight course cards use yu with the same cover/title duplicate navigation action. One constructor-level link-structure repair covers the proposed members." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The yu constructor creates each named course-image link and its separate same-course title link. Consolidating this shared course-opening structure resolves the same defect in all eight reported instances." } ], "duplicateScope": "in-scope", "canonicalDecision": "correct", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0602" }, { "errorId": "ST0603", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G231", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0603", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0603", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0603" }, { "errorId": "ST0604", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G231", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0604", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0604", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0604" }, { "errorId": "ST0605", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G231", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0605", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0605", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0605" }, { "errorId": "ST0606", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0606", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0606", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0606" }, { "errorId": "ST0607", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0607", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0607", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0607" }, { "errorId": "ST0608", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0608", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0608", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0608" }, { "errorId": "ST0609", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0609", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0609", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0609" }, { "errorId": "ST0610", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G234", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0610", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0610", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0610" }, { "errorId": "ST0611", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0611", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0611", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0611" }, { "errorId": "ST0612", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0612", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0612", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0612" }, { "errorId": "ST0613", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0613", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0613", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0613" }, { "errorId": "ST0614", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0614", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0614", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0614" }, { "errorId": "ST0615", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0615", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0615", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0615" }, { "errorId": "ST0616", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0616", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0616", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0616" }, { "errorId": "ST0617", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0617", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0617", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0617" }, { "errorId": "ST0618", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0618", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0618", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0618" }, { "errorId": "ST0619", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G234", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0619", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0619", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0619" }, { "errorId": "ST0620", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0620", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0620", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0620" }, { "errorId": "ST0621", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G235", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0621", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0621", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0621" }, { "errorId": "ST0622", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G234", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0622", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0622", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0622" }, { "errorId": "ST0623", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G232", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0606", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0606 (E045); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0623", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0623", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E045", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All duration/lecture/level strings are .course-meta fields with actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. One local course-metadata font-size correction addresses the repeated field irrespective of each course's metadata values." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata repeats .course-meta at an actual 10.88px. One course-metadata font-size change covers the repeated field across courses." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The course duration/lecture/level metadata shares .course-meta and a computed 10.88px size. A single repair to that course-metadata size covers the listed rows." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-meta\"}]；目标共享 rgb(110, 104, 116)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0623" }, { "errorId": "ST0624", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G233", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0624", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0624", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0624" }, { "errorId": "ST0625", "site": "udemy", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/21-udemy/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/21-udemy/dist", "reviewGroup": "G234", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0607", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0607 (E046); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0625", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0625", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E046", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Both colored badge variants share the same .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px. The small-text mechanism concerns this shared 0.62rem size, so a single size correction covers both variants despite their intentionally different foreground/background colors." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "All candidates are course-status badge variants and the combined .course-badge, .soft-badge declaration produces the same actual 9.92px size. Their two color variants do not change the shared font-size repair for this text_small mechanism." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Both color variants share the concrete .course-badge, .soft-badge font-size declaration and actual 9.92px size. The proposed font-size repair acts on their common size source regardless of the separate foreground/background variant colors." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.62rem\", \"file\": \"index-CxuSPZDX.css\", \"selector\": \".course-badge, .soft-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(63, 45, 0)/9.92px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 金色与紫色 badge 变体的颜色虽不同，但 text_small 的同一 .course-badge, .soft-badge 字号声明 0.62rem 只需一次修改；合并两个颜色分组。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0625" }, { "errorId": "ST0629", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G239", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0629", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0629", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0629" }, { "errorId": "ST0630", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G240", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The news cards expose different complete titles, summaries and dates. Their shared /news destination does not establish repetition of the same informational stop, and missing article destinations cannot be inferred as the link-redundancy finding." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The links are distinct articles with different titles, summaries and times. A shared /news destination is insufficient to call those information-bearing links redundant; destination behavior is not established." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The news cards carry different story titles, summaries and timestamps. Shared /news URLs do not make those distinct story entries repeated representations of one local item. No destination behavior was supplied to support a different failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The news cards expose different complete titles, summaries and dates. Their shared /news destination does not establish repetition of the same informational stop, and missing article destinations cannot be inferred as the link-redundancy finding. | B: The links are distinct articles with different titles, summaries and times. A shared /news destination is insufficient to call those information-bearing links redundant; destination behavior is not established. | C: The news cards carry different story titles, summaries and timestamps. Shared /news URLs do not make those distinct story entries repeated representations of one local item. No destination behavior was supplied to support a different failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0630", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0630", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0630" }, { "errorId": "ST0631", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G240", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The news cards expose different complete titles, summaries and dates. Their shared /news destination does not establish repetition of the same informational stop, and missing article destinations cannot be inferred as the link-redundancy finding." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The links are distinct articles with different titles, summaries and times. A shared /news destination is insufficient to call those information-bearing links redundant; destination behavior is not established." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The news cards carry different story titles, summaries and timestamps. Shared /news URLs do not make those distinct story entries repeated representations of one local item. No destination behavior was supplied to support a different failure." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The news cards expose different complete titles, summaries and dates. Their shared /news destination does not establish repetition of the same informational stop, and missing article destinations cannot be inferred as the link-redundancy finding. | B: The links are distinct articles with different titles, summaries and times. A shared /news destination is insufficient to call those information-bearing links redundant; destination behavior is not established. | C: The news cards carry different story titles, summaries and timestamps. Shared /news URLs do not make those distinct story entries repeated representations of one local item. No destination behavior was supplied to support a different failure.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0631", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0631", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0631" }, { "errorId": "ST0632", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G241", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0632", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0632", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0632" }, { "errorId": "ST0633", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G242", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0633", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0633", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0633" }, { "errorId": "ST0634", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G242", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0634", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0634", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0634" }, { "errorId": "ST0635", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G242", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0635", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0635", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0635" }, { "errorId": "ST0636", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G242", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0636", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0636", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0636" }, { "errorId": "ST0637", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G243", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0637", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0637", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0637" }, { "errorId": "ST0638", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G243", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0637", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0637 (E047); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Cd5tR9hz.css\", \"selector\": \".news-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(96, 1, 210)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0638", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0638", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E047", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The news-row category/time metadata spans share .news-row span and actual 10px. One correction to this local metadata font-size rule addresses the same repeated field across the news items." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The news category/time captions share .news-row span and an actual 10px size. One local news-metadata font-size repair covers the repeated row component." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The news category/time captions share .news-row span and an actual 10px font size. One repair to that specific news-metadata size declaration covers all listed captions." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Cd5tR9hz.css\", \"selector\": \".news-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(96, 1, 210)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0638" }, { "errorId": "ST0639", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G243", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0637", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0637 (E047); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Cd5tR9hz.css\", \"selector\": \".news-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(96, 1, 210)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0639", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0639", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E047", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The news-row category/time metadata spans share .news-row span and actual 10px. One correction to this local metadata font-size rule addresses the same repeated field across the news items." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The news category/time captions share .news-row span and an actual 10px size. One local news-metadata font-size repair covers the repeated row component." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The news category/time captions share .news-row span and an actual 10px font size. One repair to that specific news-metadata size declaration covers all listed captions." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Cd5tR9hz.css\", \"selector\": \".news-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(96, 1, 210)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0639" }, { "errorId": "ST0640", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G243", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0637", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0637 (E047); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Cd5tR9hz.css\", \"selector\": \".news-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(96, 1, 210)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0640", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0640", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E047", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The news-row category/time metadata spans share .news-row span and actual 10px. One correction to this local metadata font-size rule addresses the same repeated field across the news items." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The news category/time captions share .news-row span and an actual 10px size. One local news-metadata font-size repair covers the repeated row component." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The news category/time captions share .news-row span and an actual 10px font size. One repair to that specific news-metadata size declaration covers all listed captions." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"10px\", \"file\": \"index-Cd5tR9hz.css\", \"selector\": \".news-row span\"}]；目标共享 rgb(96, 1, 210)/10px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0640" }, { "errorId": "ST0641", "site": "finance.yahoo", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/22-finance.yahoo/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/22-finance.yahoo/dist", "reviewGroup": "G244", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0641", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0641", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0641" }, { "errorId": "ST0652", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G252", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0652", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0652", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0652" }, { "errorId": "ST0653", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G253", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0653", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0653", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0653" }, { "errorId": "ST0654", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G254", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0654", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0654", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0654" }, { "errorId": "ST0655", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G255", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0655", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0655", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0655" }, { "errorId": "ST0656", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G256", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0656", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0656", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0656" }, { "errorId": "ST0657", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G257", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0657", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0657", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0657" }, { "errorId": "ST0658", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G258", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0658", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0658", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0658" }, { "errorId": "ST0659", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G257", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0659", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0659", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0659" }, { "errorId": "ST0660", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G258", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0660", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0660", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0660" }, { "errorId": "ST0661", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G259", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0661", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0661", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0661" }, { "errorId": "ST0662", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G259", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0662", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0662", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0662" }, { "errorId": "ST0663", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "alt_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G260", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The saved accessible name of one hero link contains the full recipe title twice, once from the image alt and once from h2. Inferred consequence: the screen reader repeats the same long recipe identification on that link; the duplicate name is directly supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The one recipe link's actual AX name contains the full recipe title twice because image alt repeats the heading inside that same link. Inferred: redundant accessible-name speech during link navigation; retaining the visible title supplies the recipe identity." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "The saved AX name of one hero link repeats the complete recipe title through both image alt and h2 text. This directly supports avoidable duplicate words in the link name and inferred SR verbosity; the finding does not depend on an extra keyboard stop." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: The saved accessible name of one hero link contains the full recipe title twice, once from the image alt and once from h2. Inferred consequence: the screen reader repeats the same long recipe identification on that link; the duplicate name is directly supported by AX. | B: The one recipe link's actual AX name contains the full recipe title twice because image alt repeats the heading inside that same link. Inferred: redundant accessible-name speech during link navigation; retaining the visible title supplies the recipe identity. | C: The saved AX name of one hero link repeats the complete recipe title through both image alt and h2 text. This directly supports avoidable duplicate words in the link name and inferred SR verbosity; the finding does not depend on an extra keyboard stop.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0663", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0663", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0663" }, { "errorId": "ST0664", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G261", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX. | B: Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action. | C: Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0664", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0664", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0664" }, { "errorId": "ST0665", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G261", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX. | B: Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action. | C: Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0665", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0665", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0665" }, { "errorId": "ST0666", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G261", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX. | B: Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action. | C: Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0666", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0666", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0666" }, { "errorId": "ST0667", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G261", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX. | B: Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action. | C: Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0667", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0667", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0667" }, { "errorId": "ST0668", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G261", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX. | B: Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action. | C: Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0668", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0668", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0668" }, { "errorId": "ST0669", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G262", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Within each editorial card the article-title link and Read more navigate to the same article; one card also has its image link. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats an already available article action before Share." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Within each editorial card the named article-title link and Read more link lead to the same article; one also has an image link. Inferred: repeated sequential stops perform the same article-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each editorial card exposes its article-title link and later Read more to the same article; the second also has an image link. Within these same cards the article-opening action is repeated, adding keyboard/SR traversal; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Within each editorial card the article-title link and Read more navigate to the same article; one card also has its image link. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats an already available article action before Share. | B: Within each editorial card the named article-title link and Read more link lead to the same article; one also has an image link. Inferred: repeated sequential stops perform the same article-navigation action. | C: Each editorial card exposes its article-title link and later Read more to the same article; the second also has an image link. Within these same cards the article-opening action is repeated, adding keyboard/SR traversal; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0669", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0669", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0669" }, { "errorId": "ST0670", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G261", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Each recipe card exposes a View-recipe image link and the same recipe-title link around metadata and an independent Favorite control. Inferred consequence: repeated recipe-details stops in sequential navigation, supported by AX. | B: Each recipe card exposes a View recipe image link and a recipe-title link to the same recipe. Inferred: repeated sequential stops for the same recipe-navigation action. | C: Recipe cards expose a View-recipe image link and a separate recipe-title link to the same recipe, with favorite/metadata between them. The repeated recipe-opening action adds keyboard traversal and repeated SR naming; inferred from AX.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0670", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0670", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0670" }, { "errorId": "ST0671", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G262", "decision": "correct", "baseDecision": "correct", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Within each editorial card the article-title link and Read more navigate to the same article; one card also has its image link. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats an already available article action before Share." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Within each editorial card the named article-title link and Read more link lead to the same article; one also has an image link. Inferred: repeated sequential stops perform the same article-navigation action." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "correct", "reason": "Each editorial card exposes its article-title link and later Read more to the same article; the second also has an image link. Within these same cards the article-opening action is repeated, adding keyboard/SR traversal; inferred." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Within each editorial card the article-title link and Read more navigate to the same article; one card also has its image link. Inferred consequence: sequential navigation repeats an already available article action before Share. | B: Within each editorial card the named article-title link and Read more link lead to the same article; one also has an image link. Inferred: repeated sequential stops perform the same article-navigation action. | C: Each editorial card exposes its article-title link and later Read more to the same article; the second also has an image link. Within these same cards the article-opening action is repeated, adding keyboard/SR traversal; inferred.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0671", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0671", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0671" }, { "errorId": "ST0672", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G263", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0672", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0672", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0672" }, { "errorId": "ST0673", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G264", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0673", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0673", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0673" }, { "errorId": "ST0674", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G265", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0674", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0674", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0674" }, { "errorId": "ST0675", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G264", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0673", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0673 (E048); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".tag, .card-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0675", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0675", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E048", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe badge variants share .tag, .card-badge and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem, with matching colors in these instances. One local badge font-size adjustment addresses their common reported small-text treatment." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied recipe card badge labels share the explicit .tag, .card-badge size declaration, an actual 10.56px size, and matching colors. One badge-label font-size repair covers the same treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe badges share the explicit .tag, .card-badge font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One badge-size source change addresses the repeated text-size mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".tag, .card-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0675" }, { "errorId": "ST0676", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G265", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0674", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0674 (E049); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0676", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0676", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E049", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/editorial kicker variants share .card-kicker, .article-type and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem. Correcting that combined local kicker font-size declaration addresses all seven instances without needing per-text fixes." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These recipe/article category kickers share the explicit .card-kicker, .article-type font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One category-kicker typography change covers this common field role." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/article category labels share .card-kicker, .article-type and the computed 10.56px font size. One change to this shared category-label size declaration covers the listed fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0676" }, { "errorId": "ST0677", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G265", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0674", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0674 (E049); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0677", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0677", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E049", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/editorial kicker variants share .card-kicker, .article-type and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem. Correcting that combined local kicker font-size declaration addresses all seven instances without needing per-text fixes." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These recipe/article category kickers share the explicit .card-kicker, .article-type font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One category-kicker typography change covers this common field role." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/article category labels share .card-kicker, .article-type and the computed 10.56px font size. One change to this shared category-label size declaration covers the listed fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0677" }, { "errorId": "ST0678", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G264", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0673", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0673 (E048); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".tag, .card-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0678", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0678", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E048", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe badge variants share .tag, .card-badge and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem, with matching colors in these instances. One local badge font-size adjustment addresses their common reported small-text treatment." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The supplied recipe card badge labels share the explicit .tag, .card-badge size declaration, an actual 10.56px size, and matching colors. One badge-label font-size repair covers the same treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe badges share the explicit .tag, .card-badge font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One badge-size source change addresses the repeated text-size mechanism." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".tag, .card-badge\"}]；目标共享 rgb(255, 255, 255)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0678" }, { "errorId": "ST0679", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G265", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0674", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0674 (E049); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0679", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0679", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E049", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/editorial kicker variants share .card-kicker, .article-type and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem. Correcting that combined local kicker font-size declaration addresses all seven instances without needing per-text fixes." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These recipe/article category kickers share the explicit .card-kicker, .article-type font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One category-kicker typography change covers this common field role." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/article category labels share .card-kicker, .article-type and the computed 10.56px font size. One change to this shared category-label size declaration covers the listed fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0679" }, { "errorId": "ST0680", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G266", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0674", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0674 (E049); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0680", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0680", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E049", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/editorial kicker variants share .card-kicker, .article-type and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem. Correcting that combined local kicker font-size declaration addresses all seven instances without needing per-text fixes." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These recipe/article category kickers share the explicit .card-kicker, .article-type font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One category-kicker typography change covers this common field role." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/article category labels share .card-kicker, .article-type and the computed 10.56px font size. One change to this shared category-label size declaration covers the listed fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0680" }, { "errorId": "ST0681", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G266", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0674", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0674 (E049); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0681", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0681", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E049", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/editorial kicker variants share .card-kicker, .article-type and actual 10.56px from 0.66rem. Correcting that combined local kicker font-size declaration addresses all seven instances without needing per-text fixes." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "These recipe/article category kickers share the explicit .card-kicker, .article-type font-size declaration and actual 10.56px size. One category-kicker typography change covers this common field role." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The recipe/article category labels share .card-kicker, .article-type and the computed 10.56px font size. One change to this shared category-label size declaration covers the listed fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.66rem\", \"file\": \"index-B4c2NK2a.css\", \"selector\": \".card-kicker, .article-type\"}]；目标共享 rgb(213, 66, 21)/10.56px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0681" }, { "errorId": "ST0682", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G267", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0682", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0682", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0682" }, { "errorId": "ST0683", "site": "allrecipes", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/23-allrecipes/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/23-allrecipes/dist", "reviewGroup": "G267", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0683", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0683", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0683" }, { "errorId": "ST0707", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0707", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0707", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0707" }, { "errorId": "ST0708", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0707", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0707 (E025); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0708", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0708", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E025", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share .metric small and equal computed color/size. One specific metric-label color correction addresses this group without merging tool reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the repeated weather-metric labels share the same computed foreground from .metric small. One metric-label color repair addresses their shared source treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share the exact .metric small color source and matching computed style. One metric-label color repair covers these repeated fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0708" }, { "errorId": "ST0709", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0707", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0707 (E025); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0709", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0709", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E025", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share .metric small and equal computed color/size. One specific metric-label color correction addresses this group without merging tool reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the repeated weather-metric labels share the same computed foreground from .metric small. One metric-label color repair addresses their shared source treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share the exact .metric small color source and matching computed style. One metric-label color repair covers these repeated fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0709" }, { "errorId": "ST0710", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0707", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0707 (E025); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0710", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0710", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E025", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share .metric small and equal computed color/size. One specific metric-label color correction addresses this group without merging tool reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the repeated weather-metric labels share the same computed foreground from .metric small. One metric-label color repair addresses their shared source treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share the exact .metric small color source and matching computed style. One metric-label color repair covers these repeated fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0710" }, { "errorId": "ST0711", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0707", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0707 (E025); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0711", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0711", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E025", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share .metric small and equal computed color/size. One specific metric-label color correction addresses this group without merging tool reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the repeated weather-metric labels share the same computed foreground from .metric small. One metric-label color repair addresses their shared source treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share the exact .metric small color source and matching computed style. One metric-label color repair covers these repeated fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0711" }, { "errorId": "ST0712", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0707", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0707 (E025); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0712", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0712", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E025", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share .metric small and equal computed color/size. One specific metric-label color correction addresses this group without merging tool reports." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the repeated weather-metric labels share the same computed foreground from .metric small. One metric-label color repair addresses their shared source treatment." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE metric labels share the exact .metric small color source and matching computed style. One metric-label color repair covers these repeated fields." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(120, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".metric small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(120, 134, 154)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0712" }, { "errorId": "ST0713", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G275", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0713", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0713", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0713" }, { "errorId": "ST0714", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G275", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0713", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0713 (E029); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0714", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0714", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E029", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE these hourly probability values share the .mini-hour > small source declaration and computed text treatment. One local probability-color repair addresses the group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, repeated hourly precipitation percentages share .mini-hour > small and matching actual foreground/size. One local hourly-probability color repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the precipitation percentages share the exact .mini-hour > small foreground declaration and matching actual style. This is one repeated subcomponent color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0714" }, { "errorId": "ST0715", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G275", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0713", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0713 (E029); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0715", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0715", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E029", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE these hourly probability values share the .mini-hour > small source declaration and computed text treatment. One local probability-color repair addresses the group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, repeated hourly precipitation percentages share .mini-hour > small and matching actual foreground/size. One local hourly-probability color repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the precipitation percentages share the exact .mini-hour > small foreground declaration and matching actual style. This is one repeated subcomponent color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0715" }, { "errorId": "ST0716", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G275", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0713", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0713 (E029); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0716", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0716", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E029", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE these hourly probability values share the .mini-hour > small source declaration and computed text treatment. One local probability-color repair addresses the group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, repeated hourly precipitation percentages share .mini-hour > small and matching actual foreground/size. One local hourly-probability color repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the precipitation percentages share the exact .mini-hour > small foreground declaration and matching actual style. This is one repeated subcomponent color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0716" }, { "errorId": "ST0717", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G275", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0713", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0713 (E029); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0717", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0717", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E029", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE these hourly probability values share the .mini-hour > small source declaration and computed text treatment. One local probability-color repair addresses the group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, repeated hourly precipitation percentages share .mini-hour > small and matching actual foreground/size. One local hourly-probability color repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the precipitation percentages share the exact .mini-hour > small foreground declaration and matching actual style. This is one repeated subcomponent color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0717" }, { "errorId": "ST0718", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G275", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0713", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0713 (E029); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0718", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0718", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E029", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE these hourly probability values share the .mini-hour > small source declaration and computed text treatment. One local probability-color repair addresses the group." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, repeated hourly precipitation percentages share .mini-hour > small and matching actual foreground/size. One local hourly-probability color repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE, the precipitation percentages share the exact .mini-hour > small foreground declaration and matching actual style. This is one repeated subcomponent color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(67, 143, 196)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".mini-hour > small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(67, 143, 196)/10.72px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0718" }, { "errorId": "ST0719", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0719", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0719", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0719" }, { "errorId": "ST0720", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0719", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0719 (E026); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(126, 139, 156)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".sun-times small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(126, 139, 156)/10.4px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0720", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0720", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E026", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE sunrise/sunset labels share .sun-times small and the same actual color and size. They admit one local sun-time-label color repair." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, Sunrise and Sunset share the same sun-times label style and computed foreground. One local label-color repair covers both candidates." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE Sunrise/Sunset captions share .sun-times small and the actual text color/size. They are two instances of one local caption-color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(126, 139, 156)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".sun-times small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(126, 139, 156)/10.4px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0720" }, { "errorId": "ST0721", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0721", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0721", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0721" }, { "errorId": "ST0722", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G276", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0722", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0722", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0722" }, { "errorId": "ST0723", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0721", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0721 (E027); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(121, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(121, 134, 154)/9.76px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0723", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0723", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E027", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All WAVE insight-category labels instantiate .insight-list small with identical computed color/size. One correction to this specific category-label color rule addresses the reports together." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the insight-category labels repeat the same .insight-list small component field and actual foreground. One local category-label foreground change covers the relationship." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE insight-category labels use the same .insight-list small declaration with matching computed color. Repairing this caption color once covers all listed labels." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(121, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(121, 134, 154)/9.76px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0723" }, { "errorId": "ST0724", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G276", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0722", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0722 (E031); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(122, 135, 153)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list em\"}]；目标共享 rgb(122, 135, 153)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0724", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0724", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E031", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "These WAVE action descriptions use the same .insight-list em color rule and identical actual color/size. A single correction scoped to that repeated field is the common repair." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the insight action/explanation lines share their local .insight-list em foreground treatment and actual size. One local field-color change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE insight action descriptions use the same .insight-list em color declaration and computed foreground. They share one local description-color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(122, 135, 153)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list em\"}]；目标共享 rgb(122, 135, 153)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0724" }, { "errorId": "ST0725", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G274", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0721", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0721 (E027); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(121, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(121, 134, 154)/9.76px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0725", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0725", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E027", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "All WAVE insight-category labels instantiate .insight-list small with identical computed color/size. One correction to this specific category-label color rule addresses the reports together." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the insight-category labels repeat the same .insight-list small component field and actual foreground. One local category-label foreground change covers the relationship." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE insight-category labels use the same .insight-list small declaration with matching computed color. Repairing this caption color once covers all listed labels." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(121, 134, 154)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list small\"}]；目标共享 rgb(121, 134, 154)/9.76px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0725" }, { "errorId": "ST0726", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G276", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0722", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0722 (E031); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(122, 135, 153)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list em\"}]；目标共享 rgb(122, 135, 153)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0726", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0726", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E031", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "These WAVE action descriptions use the same .insight-list em color rule and identical actual color/size. A single correction scoped to that repeated field is the common repair." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/Weather, the insight action/explanation lines share their local .insight-list em foreground treatment and actual size. One local field-color change covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE insight action descriptions use the same .insight-list em color declaration and computed foreground. They share one local description-color repair." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"rgb(122, 135, 153)\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".insight-list em\"}]；目标共享 rgb(122, 135, 153)/11.04px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0726" }, { "errorId": "ST0727", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G277", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0727", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0727", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0727" }, { "errorId": "ST0728", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G278", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0728", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0728", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0728" }, { "errorId": "ST0729", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G278", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0728", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0728 (E050); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".eyebrow, .section-kicker\"}]；目标共享 rgb(97, 113, 138)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0729", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0729", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E050", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The weather section labels share .eyebrow, .section-kicker and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. A single local section-label font-size correction addresses Current Weather, Coming Up and the other member as instances of the same text treatment." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The current-weather/coming-up labels are section-introduction kickers sharing .eyebrow, .section-kicker and an actual 10.88px size. One shared kicker font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The weather overlines share .eyebrow, .section-kicker and an actual 10.88px font size. A single repair to that shared section-label size source addresses the reported instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".eyebrow, .section-kicker\"}]；目标共享 rgb(97, 113, 138)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0729" }, { "errorId": "ST0730", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G279", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0728", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0728 (E050); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".eyebrow, .section-kicker\"}]；目标共享 rgb(97, 113, 138)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0730", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0730", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E050", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "The weather section labels share .eyebrow, .section-kicker and actual 10.88px from 0.68rem. A single local section-label font-size correction addresses Current Weather, Coming Up and the other member as instances of the same text treatment." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "The current-weather/coming-up labels are section-introduction kickers sharing .eyebrow, .section-kicker and an actual 10.88px size. One shared kicker font-size repair covers them." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The weather overlines share .eyebrow, .section-kicker and an actual 10.88px font size. A single repair to that shared section-label size source addresses the reported instances." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"0.68rem\", \"file\": \"index-D5r94fdi.css\", \"selector\": \".eyebrow, .section-kicker\"}]；目标共享 rgb(97, 113, 138)/10.88px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0730" }, { "errorId": "ST0731", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G280", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0731", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0731", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0731" }, { "errorId": "ST0732", "site": "weather", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/24-weather/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/24-weather/dist", "reviewGroup": "G281", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0732", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0732", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0732" }, { "errorId": "ST0733", "site": "mayoclinic.org", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/25-mayoclinic.org/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/25-mayoclinic.org/dist", "reviewGroup": "G282", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Find a doctor appears in header, hero and a separate How can we help section. These are meaningful section entry points, not a demonstrated adjacent duplicate card/title stop; shared URL alone is insufficient." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Find a doctor appears in header, hero and the How can we help service choices. Those separate navigation contexts provide useful entry points, not repeated links within one same-purpose card." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "The doctor-finding links serve distinct header, hero and How can we help contexts. The reported Find a doctor Search our specialists card is not a repeated title/action pair within one adjacent card; common URLs alone do not make these contextual entrances redundant." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Find a doctor appears in header, hero and a separate How can we help section. These are meaningful section entry points, not a demonstrated adjacent duplicate card/title stop; shared URL alone is insufficient. | B: Find a doctor appears in header, hero and the How can we help service choices. Those separate navigation contexts provide useful entry points, not repeated links within one same-purpose card. | C: The doctor-finding links serve distinct header, hero and How can we help contexts. The reported Find a doctor Search our specialists card is not a repeated title/action pair within one adjacent card; common URLs alone do not make these contextual entrances redundant.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0733", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0733", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0733" }, { "errorId": "ST0735", "site": "ca.gov", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/26-ca.gov/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/26-ca.gov/dist", "reviewGroup": "G284", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0735", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0735", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0735" }, { "errorId": "ST0736", "site": "ca.gov", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/26-ca.gov/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/26-ca.gov/dist", "reviewGroup": "G285", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0736", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0736", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0736" }, { "errorId": "ST0737", "site": "ca.gov", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/26-ca.gov/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/26-ca.gov/dist", "reviewGroup": "G286", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0737", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0737", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0737" }, { "errorId": "ST0738", "site": "ca.gov", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "text_small", "rawRef": "scans/26-ca.gov/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/26-ca.gov/dist", "reviewGroup": "G286", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. Small visual font size alone does not establish a keyboard or screen-reader interaction defect. | B: Visual text size is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visually small text, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0738", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0738", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0738" }, { "errorId": "ST0743", "site": "craigslist.org", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/27-craigslist.org/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/27-craigslist.org/dist", "reviewGroup": "G289", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0743", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0743", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0743" }, { "errorId": "ST0744", "site": "craigslist.org", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/27-craigslist.org/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/27-craigslist.org/dist", "reviewGroup": "G289", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0744", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0744", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0744" }, { "errorId": "ST0745", "site": "craigslist.org", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/27-craigslist.org/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/27-craigslist.org/dist", "reviewGroup": "G289", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0745", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0745", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0745" }, { "errorId": "ST0746", "site": "craigslist.org", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/27-craigslist.org/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/27-craigslist.org/dist", "reviewGroup": "G290", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0746", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0746", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0746" }, { "errorId": "ST0747", "site": "petfinder", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "heading_possible", "rawRef": "scans/28-petfinder/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/28-petfinder/dist", "reviewGroup": "G291", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Pet care essentials is an eyebrow immediately introducing an existing descriptive h2 about dog care. Heading navigation already locates the feature; promoting the eyebrow is not needed to expose another section." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Pet care essentials is an eyebrow introducing an existing h2 Help your dog look and feel their best. The section already has a semantic heading; another heading for the eyebrow is not required for orientation." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Pet care essentials is an eyebrow paragraph immediately followed by the descriptive h2 Help your dog look and feel their best. That h2 already supplies semantic heading navigation for the feature; the eyebrow need not be another heading." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Pet care essentials is an eyebrow immediately introducing an existing descriptive h2 about dog care. Heading navigation already locates the feature; promoting the eyebrow is not needed to expose another section. | B: Pet care essentials is an eyebrow introducing an existing h2 Help your dog look and feel their best. The section already has a semantic heading; another heading for the eyebrow is not required for orientation. | C: Pet care essentials is an eyebrow paragraph immediately followed by the descriptive h2 Help your dog look and feel their best. That h2 already supplies semantic heading navigation for the feature; the eyebrow need not be another heading.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0747", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0747", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0747" }, { "errorId": "ST0752", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G295", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0752", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0752", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0752" }, { "errorId": "ST0753", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G296", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0753", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0753", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0753" }, { "errorId": "ST0754", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G296", "decision": "duplicate", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": "ST0753", "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "Outside-target duplicate of ST0753 (E052); 已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--orange)\", \"file\": \"index-Bcv9Ew9I.css\", \"selector\": \".eyebrow\"}]；目标共享 rgb(232, 83, 18)/12.16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。 Scope/validity votes retained: A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0754", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0754", "duplicateScope": "outside-target", "canonicalDecision": "excluded", "duplicateProposal": "E052", "duplicateVotes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE the two eyebrow captions share .eyebrow and the same actual color/size. One local eyebrow-color correction addresses this repeated treatment; the group remains separate from axe and outside the interaction scope, with general validity unadjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "B", "approve": true, "reason": "Within WAVE/U-Haul, the two section-eyebrow captions share the same active local .eyebrow foreground and actual size. One eyebrow-color repair covers their common source treatment without merging across tools or rejudging general accessibility validity." }, { "reviewer": "C", "approve": true, "reason": "The WAVE moving-section overlines share the exact .eyebrow color declaration and matching computed foreground. One local overline-color repair covers both within this tool, separately from axe." } ], "duplicateEvidence": "已审阅的同站同组件样式：[{\"declaration\": \"var(--orange)\", \"file\": \"index-Bcv9Ew9I.css\", \"selector\": \".eyebrow\"}]；目标共享 rgb(232, 83, 18)/12.16px，修改该局部文字样式可一并处理这些实例。", "duplicateOrigin": "three-agent-v3-excluded-same-fix-review", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0754" }, { "errorId": "ST0755", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G297", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0755", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0755", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0755" }, { "errorId": "ST0756", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G297", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0756", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0756", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0756" }, { "errorId": "ST0757", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "contrast", "ruleId": "contrast", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G297", "decision": "excluded", "baseDecision": "excluded", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "outside-target", "scopeLabel": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated in this round", "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "excluded", "reason": "The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Outside target scope; general accessibility validity not adjudicated. WAVE contrast candidates concern visual styling rather than the target interaction taxonomy. | B: Purely visual contrast mechanism is outside the requested keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity not adjudicated. | C: The reported mechanism is visual contrast, outside the specified keyboard/screen-reader interaction scope. General accessibility validity is not adjudicated.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0757", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0757", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0757" }, { "errorId": "ST0758", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G298", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Browse trailers belongs to a distinct Cargo Trailers card with its own title and explanation, while the other link serves Moving Trucks. Their common route does not prove redundant interaction or a destination failure." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Browse trailers belongs to a Cargo Trailers card, while View truck rates belongs to Moving Trucks. These are distinct offering contexts; shared URL alone does not make them redundant." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Browse trailers belongs to the Cargo Trailers card, while View truck rates belongs to a different Moving Trucks card with a different description. The shared URL does not establish duplicated local actions for the same item." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Browse trailers belongs to a distinct Cargo Trailers card with its own title and explanation, while the other link serves Moving Trucks. Their common route does not prove redundant interaction or a destination failure. | B: Browse trailers belongs to a Cargo Trailers card, while View truck rates belongs to Moving Trucks. These are distinct offering contexts; shared URL alone does not make them redundant. | C: Browse trailers belongs to the Cargo Trailers card, while View truck rates belongs to a different Moving Trucks card with a different description. The shared URL does not establish duplicated local actions for the same item.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0758", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0758", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0758" }, { "errorId": "ST0759", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G299", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Build your moving kit is a contextual entry from a separate moving-confidence section; Shop supplies appears elsewhere. Shared route does not establish an unnecessary adjacent repeated action." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Build your moving kit and Shop supplies are entry points in different substantive sections. Reusing a destination across those contexts does not demonstrate a redundant local navigation stop." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Build your moving kit belongs to a later moving-preparation section, while Shop supplies is a separate shopping entrance. Their shared supplies URL alone is insufficient to call either contextual action a redundant stop." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Build your moving kit is a contextual entry from a separate moving-confidence section; Shop supplies appears elsewhere. Shared route does not establish an unnecessary adjacent repeated action. | B: Build your moving kit and Shop supplies are entry points in different substantive sections. Reusing a destination across those contexts does not demonstrate a redundant local navigation stop. | C: Build your moving kit belongs to a later moving-preparation section, while Shop supplies is a separate shopping entrance. Their shared supplies URL alone is insufficient to call either contextual action a redundant stop.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0759", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0759", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0759" }, { "errorId": "ST0760", "site": "uhaul", "engine": "wave", "category": "alert", "ruleId": "link_redundant", "rawRef": "scans/30-uhaul/wave/attempt-1/raw.json", "distPath": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/ltl-selected31-budget-matrix-20260817/sites/30-uhaul/dist", "reviewGroup": "G300", "decision": "false-positive", "baseDecision": "false-positive", "canonicalId": null, "scope": "in-scope", "scopeLabel": null, "votes": [ { "reviewer": "A", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Moving trucks and Cargo trailers are distinct named rental categories in the footer. A shared route alone does not establish redundant information/actions, and the candidate does not provide evidence of incorrect destination content." }, { "reviewer": "B", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Moving trucks and Cargo trailers identify different rental categories in the footer. Their shared destination does not establish identical semantic actions; any destination mismatch is outside the demonstrated redundancy evidence." }, { "reviewer": "C", "decision": "false-positive", "reason": "Moving trucks and Cargo trailers identify distinct rental categories in the footer. URL equality alone does not make their semantic purposes redundant, and the destination page's behavior is not evidenced." } ], "majorityCount": 3, "unanimous": true, "note": "A: Moving trucks and Cargo trailers are distinct named rental categories in the footer. A shared route alone does not establish redundant information/actions, and the candidate does not provide evidence of incorrect destination content. | B: Moving trucks and Cargo trailers identify different rental categories in the footer. Their shared destination does not establish identical semantic actions; any destination mismatch is outside the demonstrated redundancy evidence. | C: Moving trucks and Cargo trailers identify distinct rental categories in the footer. URL equality alone does not make their semantic purposes redundant, and the destination page's behavior is not evidenced.", "humanConfirmed": false, "annotationOrigin": "three-agent-independent-evidence-review", "evidenceRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/candidate-evidence.json#errorId=ST0760", "temporalEvidence": "static DOM/AX and frozen-source inference; no new keyboard/Orca action trace", "previousReviewRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/wave-blv-annotated.json#errorId=ST0760", "previousVersionRef": "/scratch/general/vast/u6076945/generator-runs/static-a11y-selected31-20260904-r1/blv-review/multi-agent-v2/wave-reviewed.json#errorId=ST0760" } ] }